Appraisement of mathematics tasks—a point of view of Norwegian eighth-grade students

Abstract

In the large body of literature that is available about the role of motivation in mathematics education, the focus is mostly on students’ attitudes and feelings toward mathematics in general. In the current small-scale explorative study, we zoomed in on what students think about the tasks they can come across in mathematics education. To investigate students’ appraisement of mathematics tasks, that is, their judgment of how much they like mathematics tasks, we used a mixed method approach with an online questionnaire including closed and open questions. We asked 67 Norwegian eight graders to give an appraisal score for 24 tasks and to express in their own words their reasons for liking/disliking them. In addition, the students also had to indicate for each task whether they think they can solve the tasks. The analysis of the data indicated that the students may prefer bare number problems over context problems. Similarly, students inclined to like puzzle-like tasks more than estimation or straightforward tasks. The reasons for liking/disliking a task most often refer to the difficulty or easiness of the task. The data about the perceived solvability revealed that the more the students believed that they can solve the task, the more they liked the task. Given the different appraisals that the students granted to the different task types and the comments they came with, there is much reason to afford students a stronger voice in mathematics education research, particularly when it is about the tasks used in mathematics education.