Sensorineural hearing loss is a well-known complication of Streptococcus pneumoniae meningitis. Given the propensity for fibrosis and ossification of the cochlea in bacterial meningitis, implantation must be performed in a timely fashion because a delayed attempt at implantation can frustrate obtaining an optimal technical result or lead to an inability to implant. Obtaining optimal audiometric outcomes is reliant on early hearing screening in patients with streptococcal meningitis. In the absence of standardized protocols, audiometric testing is often overlooked or delayed in the workup and management of meningitis. Our institution implemented a meningitis protocol with a particular focus on timing of audiometric testing in patients with meningitis. We present a patient diagnosed with streptococcal meningitis in the first week of life. Early hearing screening allowed the diagnosis of profound unilateral sensorineural hearing loss and subsequent cochlear implantation at 10 weeks of age, the youngest described in the medical literature. Despite early implantation, there was cochlear fibrosis at the time of implantation. Fortunately, the majority of electrodes were implanted to achieve a serviceable hearing outcome. Serial magnetic resonance imaging scans were obtained because of her contralateral ventriculoperitoneal shunt that allowed unique visualization of the progression of cochlear fibrosis over time. This case demonstrates the importance of including audiometric testing in a standardized meningitis protocol to diagnose hearing loss in a timely and accurate way and to achieve optimal long-term hearing outcomes.