Are Disasters a Risk to Regional Fiscal Balance? Evidence from Indonesia

Abstract

Indonesia is an archipelago country and is fairly vulnerable to disasters. While disasters generally affect government revenue and expenditure, their effects likely vary by country. This study examines the effect of disasters on the fiscal balance, revenue, and expenditure of local governments. We used panel data and fixed effects methods to estimate the degree to which disaster severity influences budgetary solvency at the district and provincial levels in Indonesia between 2010 and 2018. This study revealed that disasters can strain fiscal balance at the district and provincial levels due to a decrease in own-source revenue and an increase in social assistance expenditure, capital expenditure, consumption expenditure, and unexpected expenditure. The district expenditure most threatened by disasters is consumption expenditure, while the provincial expenditure most threatened is unexpected expenditure. We also found that an increase in capital expenditure can lead to financial burden due to delays of planned projects or post-disaster reconstruction. Based on these findings, it is clear that some forms of insurance or other financing schemes are necessary to mitigate the adverse impacts of disasters on regional fiscal balance.

Fiscal Impacts of Climate Disasters in Emerging Markets and Developing Economies

“…Public debt increases by 2.5 percent of GDP in disaster years, reflecting lower growth, lower tax revenue, and higher spending. The impact of disasters on revenue and expenditure has been also documented for Indonesia (Wiyanti and Halimatussadiah 2021) and Pacific Island countries (Nishizawa et al 2019). A small, growing literature also focuses on the local fiscal impact.…”

Enhancing Disaster Resilience: Insights from the Cianjur Earthquake to Improve Indonesia’s Risk Financing Strategies

“…The risk posed by natural disasters has long been serious threats to Indonesia, which lack of financial and material resources constrains the country to effectively mitigate such risks (Wiyanti & Halimatussadiah, 2021). Currently, most risk-transfer mechanisms in Indonesia rely mainly on ad-hoc government relief, which is unsustainable.…”

The Fiscal Consequences of Natural Disasters: Evidence from the U.S. States

“…3 There is also a growing literature studying the fiscal effect of disaster events on subnational governments. Miao et al (2020) report in provincelevel Chinese data that disasters raise spending and intergovernmental transfers with larger effects for high-income provinces, while Wiyanti and Halimatussadiah (2021) find a significant burden on provincial fiscal balances in Indonesia due to falling revenues and rising expenditures. In the U.S. data, Chen (2020) shows that the fiscal stress experienced by localities in the New York State is not large with the cost of particularly expensive events mitigated by statutory reserve funds, whereas Liao and Kousky (2022) assess the impact of wildfires on cities in the state of California, reporting higher spending and tax collections with an overall deterioration of long-run budgetary health.…”