Are Neighborhood Effects Explained by Differences in School Quality?

Abstract

Although it is widely hypothesized that neighborhood effects are explained by differences in the schools to which children have access, few prior studies have investigated the explanatory role of school quality. In this study, we examine whether school quality mediates or interacts with the effects of neighborhood context on academic achievement. With data from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study, we operationalize a school's quality as the difference between the schoolyear and summer learning rates among its 1st grade students. We then decompose the total effect of neighborhood context on achievement at the end of 3rd, 5th, and 8th grade into components due to mediation versus interaction, which we estimate using novel counterfactual methods. Results indicate that living in a disadvantaged neighborhood substantially reduces academic achievement. But contrary to expectations, we find no evidence that neighborhood effects are mediated by or interact with school quality. The school environment does not mediate the effects of neighborhood context because differences in the socioeconomic composition of neighborhoods are not, in fact, strongly linked with differences in school quality. The school environment also does not interact with neighborhood context because attending a high-quality school is similarly beneficial whether children reside in advantaged or disadvantaged neighborhoods.

A Critical Appraisal of the Evidence on Racial Disproportionality in Special Education

“…Indeed, the diagnostic process for the most common disability category, specific learning disability, requires ruling out "exclusionary factors"social factors such as poverty, linguistic background, and lack of access to appropriate instructionas primary causes of the student's difficulties (IDEA 2004). Additionally, each of these obstacles to educational opportunity that are independent of disability status are more likely to be experienced by Black children than White children (Desimone & Long, 2010;Levy et al, 2016;Wodtke et al, 2023). Thus, test scores do not proxy for disability status, despite being correlated.…”

My School District Isn’t Segregated: Experimental Evidence on the Effect of Information on Parental Preferences Regarding School Segregation

“…Moreover, parentsparticularly affluent and well-connected parents-rely heavily on social networks and peers' opinions to inform their conceptions of what a ''good'' school looks like, irrespective of actual academic quality (Fong 2019;Holme 2002;Rhodes and Warkentien 2017). Importantly, the school attributes that advantaged parents view as high quality may not map onto the measures of effectiveness used by scholars and policymakers (Haderlein 2022;Hailey 2022a;Houston et al 2022;Wodtke, Geoffrey et al 2023).…”