Are Perceived Benefits of Heated Tobacco Products Consumption Aiding Smoking Cessation?

Abstract

Background The tobacco industry has been facing several transformations, considering that technology has evolved and health concerns have increased. One way for this industry to meet the growing social and health concerns is to provide alternative solutions. Heated tobacco products (HTPs) were the solution found, but they nevertheless pose several challenges to regulators, companies, and consumers, since HTPs are advertised as a less harmful alternative to conventional cigarettes. Focus of the Article This study aims to analyze smokers' perception of HTPs to provide insights for social marketing campaigns targeting behavioral change. Research questions The main objectives of this research are: (1) to assess whether smokers and ex-smokers view HTPs as less harmful to health than traditional cigarettes; and (2) to determine to what extent HTPs can help increase the intention to quit smoking. Methods This study explores smokers’ perception of HTPs consumption using a modified version of the Health Belief Model (HBM). A survey study involving 250 smokers and ex-smokers was conducted to test the conceptual model using PLS-Path modeling to validate the research hypotheses. The data were analyzed using the SPSS 27 and SmartPLS 3.3 programs. Results The results suggest that the perceived benefits of heated tobacco consumption negatively influence the likelihood of quitting smoking. Therefore, HTPs do not work as auxiliary products with regard to the intention to quit smoking. In some cases, the effect is quite the opposite, as HTPs use increases tobacco consumption and dependence. Perceived susceptibility and perceived severity are not significant predictors of the decision to quit smoking. Research limitations Future research could use a sample that includes only HTPs smokers and ex-smokers, analyze HTPs benefits and understand the primary motivation behind replacing conventional cigarettes with HTPs. Practical implications Entities attempting to promote the reduction of tobacco consumption should equate HTPs to conventional tobacco and focus on campaigns targeting only HTPs smokers. Whenever studying perceptions on HTPs, it is important to consider smokers’ dependence on nicotine and the particularities of the devices used to consume HTPs. Importance to the Social Marketing Field Considering the social relevance and growth of heated tobacco consumption, as well as the increase of the tobacco industry’s economic power, this research offers relevant insights into consumers’ perceptions toward HTPs.

Konstruksi Wacana Kesehatan dalam Iklan IQOS Indonesia di Channel YouTube IQOS Indonesia

“…Sebuah perusahaan Grup Philip Morris bernama Tabaqueira melakukan penelitian yang menunjukkan bahwa beralih sepenuhnya ke produk tembakau yang dipanaskan menjadi alternatif yang lebih baik daripada terus merokok. Namun, studi ini telah disponsori dan diterbitkan oleh industri itu sendiri sehingga menimbulkan permasalahan di seluruh asosiasi medis dan ilmiah serta masyarakat (Martinho et al, 2023). Meskipun kurangnya bukti yang meyakinkan mengenai efek berbahaya dari produk tembakau yang dipanaskan, kini semakin banyak bukti yang menunjukkan bahwa sistem pemanas tembakau IQOS mungkin tidak seaman klaim dari perusahaan.…”

“…Jangan sampai permasalahan tersebut justru membuat mereka menyakiti diri mereka sendiri, misalkan dengan terus mengkonsumsi rokok konvesional sebagai sebuah pelarian mereka guna mencari ketenangan. Pada kasus produk tembakau yang dipanaskan seperti IQOS ini, sebenarnya telah dipromosikan sebagai produk beresiko rendah dan ditampilkan melalui bentuk persuasi halus yang mengasosiasikan produk IQOS dengan aspirasi atau gaya hidup tertentu, hidup sehat, dan suasana bebas stress (Martinho et al, 2023).…”