Are the Same Health Warnings Effective Across Different Countries? An Experimental Study in Seven Countries

Abstract

Introduction: More than 100 countries have implemented pictorial health warnings on cigarette packages. However, few studies have compared how consumers from different geographic and cultural contexts respond to health warning content. The current study compares perceptions of warnings among adult smokers and youth in seven countries, to examine the efficacy of different health warning themes and images. Methods: Between 2010 and 2012, online and face-to-face surveys were conducted with ~500 adult smokers and ~500 youth (age 16-18) smokers and nonsmokers in each of Mexico, United States, China, Germany, India, Bangladesh, and Republic of Korea (total N = 8182). Respondents were randomized to view and rate sets of 5-7 health warnings (each set for a different health effect); each set included a text-only warning and various types (ie, themes) of pictorial warnings, including graphic health effects, "lived experience, " symbolic images, and personal testimonials. Mixedeffects models were utilized to examine perceived effectiveness of warning themes, and betweencountry differences in responses. Results: Overall, pictorial warnings were rated as more effective than text-only warnings (p < .001). Among pictorial themes, "graphic" health effects were rated as more effective than warnings depicting "lived experience" (p < .001) or "symbolic" images (p < .001). Pictorial warnings with personal testimonials were rated as more effective than the same images with didactic text (p < .001). While the magnitude of differences between warning themes varied across countries, the pattern of findings was generally consistent. Conclusions: The findings support the efficacy of graphic pictorial warnings across diverse geographic and cultural contexts, and support sharing health warning images across jurisdictions. Implications: Although over 100 countries have implemented pictorial health warnings on cigarette packages, there is little research on the most effective types of message content across geographic and cultural contexts. The current study examined perceived effectiveness of text and pictorial health warnings featuring different message content-graphic health effects, "lived experience, " personal testimonials, and symbolic imagery-among more than 8000 adults and youth in Mexico, United States, China, Germany, India, Bangladesh, and Korea. Across countries, "graphic" pictorial messages were rated as most effective. Consistencies across countries in rating message content suggests there may be "globally effective" themes and styles for designing effective health warnings.

The Potential Effectiveness of COVID-Related Smoking Cessation Messages in Three Countries

“…In addition, the study focused on smokers in high-income nations; work is needed in low- and middle-income countries where smoking rates are often high and COVID-19 has affected very large numbers of people. Previous research suggests that similar messages are likely to be effective across a wide range of countries, including low- and middle-income countries, 19 but this has yet to be tested in the context of COVID-19.…”

Roll-your-own loose tobacco packaging warning labels: a qualitative study using a novel elicitation method

“…Their participants consistently ranked health effects as more effective than those featuring ‘lived experience’ or symbolic content. However, images paired with personal testimonial text were more effective than the same images with didactic text 51. These findings suggest warning impact may vary according to participants’ familiarity with PWLs and highlight the need for on-going monitoring once PWLs have been introduced.…”

Tobacco control and household tobacco consumption: A tale of two educational groups

“…Though most of the experimental and market research evidence on the effect of health warnings on tobacco packaging is from developed countries, there is some evidence from developing countries that such health warnings reach the target audience (Alaouie, Afifi, Haddad, Mahfoud, & Nakkash, 2015;Andreeva & Krasovsky, 2011;Yong et al, 2013). A recent study also indicates that the effectiveness of pictorial warnings is generally consistent across developed and developing countries (Hammond et al, 2019).…”