Art-making in a family medicine clerkship: how does it affect medical student empathy?

Abstract

BackgroundTo provide patient-centred holistic care, doctors must possess good interpersonal and empathic skills. Medical schools traditionally adopt a skills-based approach to such training but creative engagement with the arts has also been effective. A novel arts-based approach may help medical students develop empathic understanding of patients and thus contribute to medical students’ transformative process into compassionate doctors. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of an arts-making workshop on medical student empathy.MethodsThis was a mixed-method quantitative-qualitative study. In the 2011–12 academic year, all 161 third year medical students at the University of Hong Kong were randomly allocated into either an arts-making workshop or a problem-solving workshop during the Family Medicine clerkship according to a centrally-set timetable. Students in the arts-making workshop wrote a poem, created artwork and completed a reflective essay while students in the conventional workshop problem-solved clinical cases and wrote a case commentary. All students who agreed to participate in the study completed a measure of empathy for medical students, the Jefferson Scale of Empathy (JSE) (student version), at the start and end of the clerkship. Quantitative data analysis: Paired t-test and repeated measures ANOVA was used to compare the change within and between groups respectively. Qualitative data analysis: Two researchers independently chose representational narratives based on criteria adapted from art therapy. The final 20 works were agreed upon by consensus and thematically analysed using a grounded theory approach.ResultsThe level of empathy declined in both groups over time, but with no statistically significant differences between groups. For JSE items relating to emotional influence on medical decision making, participants in the arts-making workshop changed more than those in the problem-solving workshop. From the qualitative data, students perceived benefits in arts-making, and gained understanding in relation to self, patients, pain and suffering, and the role of the doctor.ConclusionsThough quantitative findings showed little difference in empathy between groups, arts-making workshop participants gained empathic understanding in four different thematic areas. This workshop also seemed to promote greater self-awareness which may help medical students recognize the potential for emotions to sway judgment. Future art workshops should focus on emotional awareness and regulation.

Medical student mandala making for holistic well-being

“…The curriculum also aims to help medical students enhance self-awareness for both self-care and in order to improve patient care, 1 2 Through such training, it is hoped that doctors will achieve a better balance in their emotional, psychological and spiritual aspects. Building on our earlier work exploring the use of art to enhance empathy among medical students, 3 4 we present the findings from an arts-based workshop designed to both understand and help medical students cope with their psychosocial stressors.…”

Medical Humanities Coursework Is Associated with Greater Measured Empathy in Medical Students

“…Yang and Yang 17 found that a 4-hour experience with interpreting paintings did not influence medical students' scores on the JSE-S and called for further experimental investigations. Potash et al 18 compared a group of students who made art with a group of students who experienced a "problem-solving" workshop; empathy declined in both groups, without a statistical difference in outcome.…”

Medical Student Interpretation of Visual Art: Who's Got Empathy?

“…A recent review points to the value of incorporating the arts in medical education, especially for teaching self-awareness, openness to other perspectives, and empathy (Haidet et al, 2016). Another study of 3 rd year University of Hong Kong medical students using the JSE as a pre-post measure found that, while the level of empathy declined in both groups over time, with no statistically significant differences between the intervention and control groups, the qualitative data showed that students in an arts-making condition gained insight into self, patients, pain and suffering, and the role of the physician (Potash et al, 2014).…”