Finite mixture models are clustering methods gaining more and more popularity recently. They also show many advantages in comparison to traditional clustering techniques (e.g., k-means cluster analysis). However, contrarily to techniques relying on classification algorithms, mixture models are not able to classify unseen or future cases in clusters previously identified. Hence, this study proposes a novel multistep approach to predict group membership using clusters obtained through a Latent Profile Analysis (LPA) as reference labels. A representative sample of 1,002 Italian individuals was used, with 802 participants randomly selected for initial analysis. Four Machine Learning (ML) algorithms - Artificial Neural Networks, Random Forest, Gradient Boosting, and Support Vector Machines - were trained and evaluated, relying on grid search and k-fold cross-validation. Results indicated high accuracy across algorithms, with Support Vector Machines (SVM) exhibiting the highest performance (95.3%). To further assess generalization capacity, a second subset of 200 individuals was analysed, with labels suggested by a second LPA from the total dataset (N = 1,002) used as reference. Trained ML models achieved notable accuracy in predicting cluster membership for this second subset (SVM accuracy = 90%). Overall, the study demonstrates ML efficacy in predictive clustering, offering a robust framework for future research.