“As Good As It Gets”: Undocumented Latino Day Laborers Negotiating Discrimination in San Francisco and Berkeley, California, USA

Abstract

Undocumented Latino day laborers in the United States are vulnerable to being arrested and expelled at any time. This social fact shapes their everyday lives in terms of actions taken and strategies deployed to mitigate being confronted, profiled, and possibly incarcerated and deported. While perceptions of threat and bouts of discrimination are routine among undocumented Latino day laborers, their specific nature vary according to multiple social factors and structural forces that differ significantly from locale to locale. The experience of discrimination is often tacitly negotiated through perceptions, decisions, and actions toward avoiding or moderating its ill effects. This essay examines urban undocumented Latino day laborers over a variety of sites in the greater San Francisco Bay Area, which, compared to many metropolitan areas in the U.S. is “as good as it gets” in terms of being socially tolerated and relatively safe from persecution. Nonetheless, tacit negotiations are necessary to withstand or overcome challenges presented by idiosyncratic and ever changing global, national/state, and local dynamics of discrimination. [undocumented Latino laborers, social exclusion, discrimination, tacit negotiation]

Documents and Shifting Labor Environments Among Undocumented Migrant Workers in Northern California

“…The result among day laborers in Berkeley was a migrant experience where tolerance and inclusion produced a form of belonging close to citizenship that paralleled much of its recognizable contours, but that carried within its basic premises contradictions that led the men to a self‐imposed attitude of isolation and avoidance of most institutions (the police, health services, and NGO staff of all kinds). Similar attitudes have been noted throughout the Bay Area where migrants hear stories of deportation and disappearance after even the most innocuous interactions with police officers, for example (Quesada ; Quesada et al ). This parallel citizenship points to the impossible nature of belonging for migrants caught between inclusion and exclusion in a system of social referents that are built upon the confusion and rumors of the state's illegibility.…”

Living Conditions and Psychological Distress in Latino Migrant Day Laborers: The Role of Cultural and Community Protective Factors

“…'s () model of structural vulnerability, the living and working conditions of predominately undocumented LMDLs are remarkably similar across different United States city and state settings. In fact, the San Francisco Bay Area may be “As good as it gets” (Quesada et al., ) for LMDLs as compared to states with more severe immigration control policies, such as Arizona, which prohibits day laborers from soliciting work in public, and disallows operating day labor centers that typically support LMDLs in myriad ways beyond organizing work (i.e., health education, wage theft recovery, etc. ).…”

Immigration as a Social Determinant of Health

“…Whether voluntary or involuntary, migration poses challenges to individuals and communities, requiring an almost complete realignment of daily life that can have significant social, economic, and health consequences (110). Although immigration is a consequence of social determinants, such as poverty, occupational and educational opportunities, and political persecution, immigration must also be positioned as a social determinant in its own right.…”