Asking what matters: The relevance and use of patient‐reported outcome measures that were developed without patient involvement

Abstract

BackgroundPatient‐reported outcome measures (PROMs) are increasingly used to establish the value of health care. In order to reflect value, PROMs should measure outcomes that matter to patients. However, patients are not always involved in the development of PROMs. This study therefore aimed to investigate whether PROMs, which were developed without patient involvement, are relevant to patients and whether the level of importance allocated towards aspects of these PROMs varies between patient groups.MethodsAll patients from 20 Dutch hospitals undergoing hip or knee surgery in 2014 were invited to a PROMs survey. Participants were asked to rate the importance of each of the items in the HOOS‐Physical Function Short form or the KOOS‐Physical Function Short form, the EQ‐5D and the NRS pain.ResultsMost outcomes were considered important. However, 77.7% of hip surgery patients rated being able to run as unimportant. Being able to kneel (32.7%) or squat (39.6%) was not important to a considerable minority of knee surgery patients. Pain, especially during rest, was considered very important by both hip (68.2%) and knee (66.5%) surgery patients. Patients who were older, male, experienced overall bad health and psychological health considered many items from the PROMs less important than other patients.DiscussionPatients differ in what they consider important. Health‐care professionals should explore patients’ preferences and discuss which treatment options best fit patients’ preferences. Additionally, if PROMs are used in performance measurement, further research is needed to look at whether and how variation in patient preferences can be taken into account.

Using PROMs during routine medical consultations: The perspectives of people with Parkinson’s disease and their health professionals

“…Using PROMs during routine medical consultations by health professionals and patients would suit current ideas on person‐centred medicine and shared decision making . .…”

“…However, patients do not find all PROMs equally relevant or even bothersome or unnecessarily confronting, and such perceptions may well hinder the adoption of PROMs into daily clinical practice. Several previous studies have therefore involved patients into developing PROMs . Also, studies have shown that meaningful and comprehensible presentation of PROMs data is important to help patients with interpreting the data correctly and with using the data in important medical decisions, such as choosing a particular type of treatment or health‐care provider .…”

“…Several previous studies have therefore involved patients into developing PROMs. 10,15 Also, studies have shown that meaningful and comprehensible presentation of PROMs data is important to help patients with interpreting the data correctly and with using the data in important medical decisions, such as choosing a particular type of treatment or health-care provider. [16][17][18][19][20] Although a majority of patients seems to correctly interpret PROMs information (displayed through various formats), a substantial portion (10%-30% across studies) continues to experience trouble with interpretation, resulting in an inaccurate understanding of the information.…”

Carfilzomib Induced Cardiotoxicity in a Multiple Myeloma Patient

“…(15) (16). For this reason it is extremely important to offer interdisciplinary management with the cardio-oncology team, explore the patient preferences and discuss which treatment options best ts the patient needs (17).…”

Entertaining accurate treatment expectations while suffering from chronic pain: an exploration of treatment expectations and the relationship with patient- provider communication

“…Patient expectations of treatment outcomes can be very important for achieving optimal treatment success. Patient expectations can not only influence satisfaction after treatment, [ 1 – 3 ] but also patient outcomes [ 4 – 6 ], the number of return visits [ 7 ] and self-care [ 6 ]. However, research shows that many patients harbour inaccurate expectations regarding treatment outcomes [ 8 – 11 ].…”