Assessing DEM interpolation methods for effective representation of upland stream morphology for rapid appraisal of bed stability

Abstract

Digital elevation models (DEMs) of river channels, built by interpolation between samples of topographic survey points, are widely used to represent surfaces and to derive land‐surface parameters. Differencing between successive DEMs permits quantification of change, which in gravel‐bed rivers is used to construct a morphological budget of lower bound estimates of sediment flux and bed‐stability surrogate. Choice of DEM interpolation method strongly influences DEM quality and realistic representation of channel forms. When comparing morphological budgets between multiple contrasting reaches, e.g. for rapid ecological appraisal, an effective and consistent means of DEM construction is required to avoid digitally generated inconsistencies. An appropriate interpolation method should be suitable for accurate representation of channels contrasting in substrate and hydraulic conditions, surveys of varying data density and distribution, and avoidance of site‐specific parameterization. This paper investigates representation of channel form using a series of DEMs generated within Surfer® by triangulation with linear interpolation, natural neighbours, point kriging, universal kriging, multiquadratic radial basis function, modified Shepard's method and inverse distance to a power on the example of four reaches of mountain streams in New Zealand. These reaches represent a diversity of channel forms, substrate and hydraulic properties. DEMs from triangulation with linear interpolation revealed consistently the best results and this method is recommended for geomorphological and ecological studies of multiple reaches. The main advantage over point kriging and radial basis function is better representation of channel margins and bedforms without introduction of breaklines, while it outperforms natural neighbours in honouring measured points. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Multi-scale influence of vapor pressure deficit on fire ignition and spread in boreal forest ecosystems

“…By establishing a minimum number of known locations to be included in the analysis, IDW limits its sensitivity to outliers and ensures the robustness of the interpolation. This interpolation method has been extensively used to retrieve continuous representations of a variety of environmental variables such as precipitation, temperature, or elevation from point data (Chen and Liu, 2012;Didari et al, 2012;Schwendel et al, 2012). While more sophisticated statistical interpolation methods, such as kriging, exist, their more severe assumptions cannot be always met and their increasing complexity commonly requires a larger number of empirical parameters.…”

Mapping the daily progression of large wildland fires using MODIS active fire data

“…precipitation, elevation, frost, air temperature) based on discontinuous point data (e.g. Holdaway 1996;Schwendel et al 2012). The values at unknown locations are calculated based on a combination of the distance to the known locations and the spatial arrangement of the known locations.…”

Monitoring Riverbank Erosion in Mountain Catchments Using Terrestrial Laser Scanning

“…This result turned out to be quite different from what has been reported by other authors. For example, Schwendel et al [84] argue that very large discrepancies can be obtained from the application of different interpolators, although the initial point density in the data set they adopted was rather scarce. In fact, in that study a set of RTK-GPS points was used.…”