In the big data era, managers are exposed to an increasing amount of structured and unstructured information that they must process daily to make decisions. In this context, artificial intelligence (AI) functionalities can support managerial information processing (IP), which forms the basis of managers' decision-making. To date, little is known about the themes that managers face when integrating AI into their IP and decision-making. The present paper identifies these through three focus group interviews with managers from the financial industry, validates them through a survey and derives organizational implications. The results imply that organizations should (1) evaluate managerial IP tasks and matching AI systems, (2) (re)define roles for managers and AI systems, and (3) redesign management processes for sustainable human-AI interaction.