Assessing the effect of empathy-enhancing interventions in health education and training: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials

Abstract

ObjectiveTo estimate the effect of empathy interventions in health education and training from randomised controlled trials (RCTs).MethodsMEDLINE, PsycINFO, EMBASE, CINAHL and Cochrane databases were searched from inception to June 2019 for RCTs investigating the effect of empathy-enhancing interventions in medical and healthcare students and professionals. Studies measuring any aspect of ‘clinical empathy’ as a primary or secondary outcome were included. Two reviewers extracted data and assessed the risk of bias of eligible studies using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool. Random effects meta-analyses of the impact of empathy training on participants’ empathy levels were performed.ResultsTwenty-six trials were included, with 22 providing adequate data for meta-analysis. An overall moderate effect on participant empathy postintervention (standardised mean difference 0.52, 95% CI 0.36 to 0.67) was found. Heterogeneity across trial results was substantial (I2=63%). Data on sustainability of effect was provided by 11 trials and found a moderate effect size for improved empathy up until 12 weeks (0.69, 95% CI 0.23 to 1.15), and a small but statistically significant effect size for sustainability at 12 weeks and beyond (standardised mean difference 0.34, 95% CI 0.11 to 0.57). In total, 15 studies were considered to be either unclear or high risk of bias. The quality of evidence of included studies was low.ConclusionFindings suggest that empathy-enhancing interventions can be effective at cultivating and sustaining empathy with intervention specifics contributing to effectiveness. This review focuses on an important, growing area of medical education and provides guidance to those looking to develop effective interventions to enhance empathy in the healthcare setting. Further high-quality trials are needed that include patient-led outcome assessments and further evaluate the long-term sustainability of empathy training.Protocol registration numberPROSPERO (CRD42019126843).

Role of primary care physician factors on diagnostic testing and referral decisions for symptoms of possible cancer: a systematic review

“…‘Gut feeling’ is associated with empathy72 and underpinned by clinical knowledge and experience 73 74. Thus, the ability of PCPs to access and leverage 'gut feeling' in interventions for enhancing empathy75 may be more instinctive to some PCPs than others. Though years of experience is not modifiable, clinical experience may be more important and mutable through simulated diagnostic experiences that increase exposure to presentations that could be due to cancer 76…”

Association of Autism Spectrum Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Traits with Depression and Empathy Among Medical Students

“…27 Among medical students with strong ASD traits, some interventions are particularly needed for depression prevention and improved empathy. Despite the effectiveness of communication skills and mindfulness training for improving empathy in medical students, 28–30 developing interventions for medical students with ASD traits continues to remain a challenge. Among the AQ subscales (social skills, attention switching, attention to detail, communication, and imagination), social skills significantly predicted decreased empathy and helping motivation in adults with ASD.…”

Can stoic training develop medical student empathy and resilience? A mixed-methods study

“…Empathic erosion, defined as a loss of empathy, and burnout, a syndrome characterized by emotional exhaustion, cynicism and a low perception of accomplishment [ 1 ], are related - those exhibiting signs of burnout have less capacity to display empathy. Yet, training programmes which aim to cultivate empathy and personal resilience (a concept that protects against burnout) [ 2 ] are underdeveloped [ 3 , 4 ]. There is an ongoing need for research into training within medical education that can combat rising levels of empathic erosion and burnout.…”