Assessing the Effects of Stove Use Patterns and Kitchen Chimneys on Indoor Air Quality during a Multiyear Cookstove Randomized Control Trial in Rural India

Abstract

We conducted indoor air quality (IAQ) measurements during a multiyear cookstove randomized control trial in two rural areas in northern and southern India. A total of 1205 days of kitchen PM2.5 were measured in control and intervention households during six ∼3 month long measurement periods across two study locations. Stoves used included traditional solid fuel (TSF), improved biomass, and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) models. Intent-to-treat analysis indicates that the intervention reduced average 24 h PM2.5 and black carbon in only one of the two follow-up measurement periods in both areas, suggesting mixed effectiveness. Average PM2.5 levels were ∼50% lower in households with LPG (for exclusive LPG use: >75% lower) than in those without LPG. PM2.5 was 66% lower in households making exclusive use of an improved chimney stove versus a traditional chimney stove and TSF-exclusive kitchens with a built-in chimney had ∼60% lower PM2.5 than those without a chimney, indicating that kitchen ventilation can be as important as the stove technology in improving IAQ. Diurnal trends in real-time PM2.5 indicate that kitchen chimneys were especially effective at reducing peak concentrations, which leads to decreases in daily PM2.5 in these households. Our data demonstrate a clear hierarchy of IAQ improvement in real world, “stove-stacking” households, driven by different stove technologies and kitchen characteristics.

Widespread Clean Cooking Fuel Scale-Up and under-5 Lower Respiratory Infection Mortality: An Ecological Analysis in Ecuador, 1990–2019

“… 5 , 10 – 12 Still, evidence from randomized controlled trials and observational studies shows that, when clean-burning fuels like gas and electricity largely displace the use of polluting fuels like firewood, dung, and charcoal, personal air pollution exposures can be dramatically reduced—and even be close—to exposures designated in health-based exposure guidelines. 6 , 11 , 13 – 20 These studies are supported by laboratory- and field-based emissions estimates that indicate that the magnitude of health-damaging pollutants released during cooking is dramatically reduced when using gas stoves vs. biomass stoves. 21 , 22 …”

Spatio-temporal Variation of Meteorological Influence on PM2.5 and PM10 over Major Urban Cities of Bangladesh

“…The model used Log-transformed PM time series (as the dependent variable) because PM concentration had been mathematically shown to have lognormal distribution (Ott, 1990). Many studies -investigating indoor (Islam et al, 2022c;Young et al, 2019) and outdoor PM concentrations (Beckerman et al, 2013) and PM emissions (Islam et al, 2021) -found the same and used logarithmic PM distribution in models/analyses. In our dataset, the logarithm of daily PM concentration follows normal distribution determined by Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (p = 0.0049 and 0.0710 for PM2.5 and log(PM2.5), respectively and p = 0.0035 and 0.0821 for PM10 and log(PM10), respectively).…”

Scaling up gas and electric cooking in low- and middle-income countries: climate threat or mitigation strategy with co-benefits?

“…Unlike electricity and piped natural gas, LPG does not require major investment in infrastructure to scale. It is clean-burning and simple to use [14,15]. Electricity accounts for most of the remaining increase in primary access to clean cooking.…”