Assessing the Quality of YouTube Videos on Adhesive Capsulitis

Abstract

IntroductionYouTube is the most popular video-based source of information on the Internet. It is accessed by over 1 billion users, which approximates to almost one-third of all Internet users. Orthopaedic video content published on YouTube is not screened and does not go through an editorial process, and most videos do not have information about authorship or appropriate references. Users who do not have the knowledge to assess the accuracy and reliability of the source may be misinformed about their medical condition. Previous studies have evaluated the quality of YouTube content for information in orthopaedics such as meniscus, kyphosis, and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), but the quality of frozen shoulder videos on YouTube has not been investigated. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the quality and educational value of YouTube videos concerning adhesive capsulitis. MethodsA YouTube search was performed using the term "frozen shoulder." Videos were excluded if they had no audio, were in a language other than English, or were longer than 10 minutes. A total of 70 videos were screened, and the first 50 videos that met the inclusion criteria were evaluated by three observers. Six video characteristics were extracted, and videos were categorized by source and content. Quality and educational value were assessed using the DISCERN (score range, 0-5), Global Quality score (GQS; score range, 0-4), and a Frozen Shoulder-Specific Score (FSSS; score range, 0-16). ResultsThe mean video duration was 242.46 ± 164.32 seconds. The mean number of views was 137,494 ± 262,756 and the total view count across 50 videos was 6,874,706. The mean DISCERN, GQS, and FSSS scores were 2.72 ± 0.85, 2.37 ± 0.895, and 4.42 ± 3.15, respectively. The video sources were primarily from non-physician healthcare professionals (32%), and most of the video content was focused on disease-specific information (50%). Significant between-group effects were observed for the DISCERN score and video source (P = .005), with videos from academic sources having the highest mean DISCERN score. DISCERN scores also differed significantly based on video content (P = .007), with disease content having the highest DISCERN score. Both GQS and FSSS scores differed significantly based on video content (both P < .001) but did not differ significantly based on the video source. ConclusionsInformation about frozen shoulder on YouTube is low quality and has limited educational value. Thus, providers for orthopaedic conditions should warn their patients and provide better alternatives for education.

Evaluation of online video content related to reverse shoulder arthroplasty: a YouTube-based study

“…In general, YouTube videos proved to be a poor online source for information regarding RSA, as shown by the poor quality scores attained. This falls in line with other YouTube-based studies in the literature that reported a low quality of information for orthopedic-related pathologies and procedures [ 7 , 16 , 20 , 21 , 24 ]. The unrestricted ability to upload videos and the lack of editorial evaluation on accuracy and comprehensiveness of content are potential contributors to the low scores exhibited in our study [ 8 ].…”

“…A maximum score of five indicates excellent quality and flow. Although the GQS assessment is unvalidated, this tool has been used in numerous YouTube-based studies in the orthopedic literature [ 16 , 17 ].…”

Ausência de recursos didáticos de alta qualidade sobre a capsulite adesiva no YouTube

“…However, this method has been used before. 10,12 At the same time, although we evaluated the adhesive capsulitis videos by expanding the search terms in this study, we assume that we obtained similar data to the findings of Tang et al 9 The internet has made it easier than ever to access information on any topic imaginable. However, this also means a lot of misinformation and disinformation is available online.…”

Analyzing the Quality, Reliability, and Educational Value of ACL Rehabilitation Exercises on TikTok: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…19,34 However, the present study reflects the findings of other studies evaluating YouTube as a source of information pertaining to ACL, meniscus, kyphosis, and adhesive capsulitis. 5,9,21,35 While the content uploaders should assume responsibility for the quality of their videos, the poor quality of medically related TikTok videos could stem from other factors. TikTok relies on short video playtime and engagement times that may not allow for appropriate citation of sources or thorough discussion of rationale, risks, benefits, and safety precautions.…”