Assessing the sustainability of wheat-based cropping systems using simulation modelling: sustainability = 42?

Abstract

Concepts of agricultural sustainability and possible roles of simulation modelling for characterising sustainability were explored by conducting, and reflecting on, a sustainability assessment of rain-fed wheat-based systems in the Middle East and North Africa region. We designed a goal-oriented, model-based framework using the cropping systems model Agricultural Production Systems sIMulator (APSIM). For the assessment, valid (rather than true or false) sustainability goals and indicators were identified for the target system. System-specific vagueness was depicted in sustainability polygons-a system property derived from highly quantitative data-and denoted using descriptive quantifiers. Diagnostic evaluations of alternative tillage practices demonstrated the utility of the framework to quantify key bio-physical and chemical constraints to sustainability. Here, we argue that sustainability is a vague, emergent system property of often wicked complexity that arises out of more fundamental elements and processes. A 'wicked concept of sustainability' acknowledges the breadth of the human experience of sustainability, which cannot be internalised in a model. To achieve socially desirable sustainability goals, our model-based approach can inform reflective evaluation processes that connect with the needs and values of agricultural decision-makers. Hence, it can help to frame meaningful discussions, from which actions might emerge.

Distributed renewable economy for Africa as a basis for wellbeing economy development

“…A key challenge in adopting an approach of doing science with society is to develop solution-oriented, or transformative transdisciplinary research approaches that are capable of not only explaining and understanding the complex societal challenges currently being faced in the world, but also of changing or transforming these challenges (Breda & Swilling, 2018;Miller et al, 2014;Scholz, 2011;Seidl et al, 2013;Stauffacher, Walter, Lang, Wiek & Scholz, 2006;Wiek & Lang, 2016). The transdisciplinary field started to emerge from the increasing recognition of the urgent need to generate solutions based on understanding dynamic complexity (Mebratu, 2000).…”

Sensitivity Analysis in Socio-Ecological Models as a Tool in Environmental Policy for Sustainability

“…Indicators could represent useful tools to compare the impacts of the alternative options [42,43]. This work shows how a selection of seven indicators (Table 1) would react to different policy measures.…”

“…The establishment of thresholds for each indicator is a clear step forward in sustainability since they represent a reference for decisions and quantify what is acceptable regarding sustainability goals [43]. When there were no published thresholds for an indicator, a value was established based on a proportion of the value adopted for that indicator in 2009, when Fuerteventura was declared a Biosphere Reserve [44].…”

Long-term cropping system studies support intensive and responsive cropping systems in the low-rainfall Australian Mallee

“…Simulated crop growth is driven by radiation-use efficiency modified according to temperature, and with stress indices calculated from available water and N used to reduce yield further. In systems where water and N limitation are primary drivers of plant growth, models have been usefully applied (Hunt and Kirkegaard 2011;Moeller et al 2014). However, the response of a crop to other nutrient constraints and biotic stresses is not captured by most models.…”