Assessing the Variability of the Twelfth Rib as a Landmark for Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy Using Computed Tomography

Abstract

Background The variability in length of the twelfth rib is mentioned in the literature but has never been formally studied. The highly variable rib length provides a challenge for urologists seeking a consistent landmark for Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (PCNL). We set out to determine whether the twelfth rib is safe to use as a consistent landmark for surgery. Methods Single centre, cross-sectional retrospective observational study and analysis of CT scans of 100 adults who had imaging between 23rd March and 12th April 2020. The distance from the mid-sagittal line to the twelfth rib tip in the axial plane was measured as was the distance from the twelfth rib tip to the kidney, spleen and liver. Results Length from the mid-sagittal line to the right twelfth rib tip varied from 46 (percentile 95% CI 40 to 57) to 136mm (percentile 95% CI 133 to 138). On the left, the distances varied from 55 (percentile 95% CI 50 to 64) to 134mm (percentile 95% CI 131 to 135). Twenty-three percent of people had an organ lying between the tip of the twelfth rib and the kidney on the right and 11% on the left. Conclusion The twelfth rib is highly variable in length. Similar variability was recorded in the distance from the tip to intra-abdominal organs. Due to the frequency of organs lying between the tip of the rib and the kidney it should not be used as a landmark for accessing the kidney without prior knowledge of an individual patient’s anatomy as seen on imaging.