Assessment of Adaptive Reuse Practices through User Experiences: Traditional Houses in the Walled City of Nicosia

Abstract

The conservation of traditional residential architecture is crucial in terms of sociocultural continuity. When the traditional houses are no longer used for residential purposes, new functions should be assigned to them for the continuity of the heritage buildings. However, new functions should respect the originality of the heritage building. This research focuses on the conservation and reuse of traditional houses located in the walled city of Nicosia. The walled city is divided into two parts as north and south with a buffer zone between the two. This paper includes case studies of re-functioned traditional houses from the two parts. The study questions the appropriateness of the new functions that have been assigned to the traditional houses both in the northern and southern parts of the city. This research aims to measure and compare the success of the adaptive reuse practices through user experiences. As the method of study, the literature survey was carried out to identify different aspects of adaptive reuse projects. Then, selected buildings were observed through site surveys in order to discover the current condition of the adaptive reuse projects. The third step was to complete the questionnaires with different users in order to question the success of the adaptive reuse projects through the user experience. Finally, the collected data were evaluated and discussed. The respondents were asked to answer questions about each building, which are organized under the three categories of sociocultural, economic, and physical aspects of the heritage buildings. As observed with the evaluated case studies, heritage buildings that are re-functioned with the public use, such as commercial, cultural, and educational use, are more successful in contributing to the sociocultural and economic development of the city. The preservation and reuse of abandoned traditional houses in the walled city contribute to the continuity and livability of the city. For the continuity of the heritage buildings, sociocultural, economic, and physical aspects should be taken into consideration with a holistic approach.

The Use of Natural Stone as an Authentic Building Material for the Restoration of Historic Buildings in Order to Test Sustainable Refurbishment: Case Study

“…Adaptive re-use of the Haybarn Complex confirmed the assertion made by Mısırlısoy and Günçe [1], that the most appropriate adaptive re-use strategy has a vital importance for heritage building conservation and maintenance of cultural, economic and social values. The authors of this study concluded the same as Mısırlısoy and Günçe [5] that the materials used for restoration should be in harmony with the original materials and in accordance with the structural integrity of the building and space demands of new function activities.…”

“…When it comes to interventions, they also need to be carried out without harming the quality impartment and integrity of the building itself. The new function of the restored building must complement its space requirements [5].…”

“…A successfully realized adaptive re-use increases the value of the property and might also contribute to cultural tourism. The physical survival of heritage buildings is not enough-these buildings are to be economically sustainable as well [5].…”

New Uses for Old Buildings: The case of 'Soğukçeşme Street, İstanbul, Turkey

“…In the contemporary era, adaptive reuse has been considered as a strategy for protecting these buildings for both present and future generations. At present, the 19th and 20th century conservation and restoration theories are the backbone of the contemporary adaptation movement by introducing different forms of adaptive reuse over time (Günçe & Mısırlısoy, 2019;Yazdani Mehr, 2019).…”

Nodes and Networks: The Generative Role of Cultural Heritage for Urban Revival in Kikinda

“…Nevertheless, there are also some authors claiming that adaptive reuse strategies should be created to use traditional houses "with their original functions or appropriate functions with the authenticity of the original function" [20] (p. 12). This approach is not well suited for the contemporary tendencies shown above that combine adaptive reuse with the new compatible uses.…”