syndrome was present in both lungs at autopsy, the changes being stated t o be of three to four days duration. Increase in the lung water may be a feature of this condition. It remains speculative as to whether pulmonary edema alone was the cause of the left sided change though as the paper states this seemed most likely.With respect to Dr Nikolic's comment on Figure 2, we have not sought to distinguish between areas of normal and hyperperfusion on the lung scan, believing that such distinction might be suspect in absolute terms. The scan seeks to show discrete areas of relative hypoperfusion. It was, in any case, performed some three days after the resolution of the asymmetric change, at a time of diffused alveolar change in both lung fields.It may be difficult to form valid conclusions about dynamic states in the living from post mortem angiograph y.The patient was on positive end expired pressure ranging between five and ten centimeters of water pressure for the entire duration of assisted ventilation.In response t o the final question raised, the patient was fully heparinised from the first post-operative day, when the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism was suspect. Two days later heparinisation was ceased, the patient's clinical feature at the time suggesting that the disturbance in pulmonary gas transfer was due to the diffuse parenchymal lung lesion rather than pulmonary embolism. In fact, both conditions were present and cessation of heparin therapy was in retrospect unwise. This is the essential thrust of the case report, that is, that unilateral alveolar consolidation may co-exist with pulmonary artery obstruction and may in fact result from it. The physician should be alerted to this hazardous possibility.Heparinisation was recommenced when the results of the lung scan were known. The development of the bilateral diffuse alveolar change meant that both the lung scan and the pulmonary angiography were performed in an extremely hypoxic patient.I would like to thank Dr Nikolic for his interest and his comments.