Assigning protein function from domain-function associations using DomFun

Abstract

Background Protein function prediction remains a key challenge. Domain composition affects protein function. Here we present DomFun, a Ruby gem that uses associations between protein domains and functions, calculated using multiple indices based on tripartite network analysis. These domain-function associations are combined at the protein level, to generate protein-function predictions. Results We analysed 16 tripartite networks connecting homologous superfamily and FunFam domains from CATH-Gene3D with functional annotations from the three Gene Ontology (GO) sub-ontologies, KEGG, and Reactome. We validated the results using the CAFA 3 benchmark platform for GO annotation, finding that out of the multiple association metrics and domain datasets tested, Simpson index for FunFam domain-function associations combined with Stouffer’s method leads to the best performance in almost all scenarios. We also found that using FunFams led to better performance than superfamilies, and better results were found for GO molecular function compared to GO biological process terms. DomFun performed as well as the highest-performing method in certain CAFA 3 evaluation procedures in terms of $$F_{max}$$ F max and $$S_{min}$$ S min We also implemented our own benchmark procedure, Pathway Prediction Performance (PPP), which can be used to validate function prediction for additional annotations sources, such as KEGG and Reactome. Using PPP, we found similar results to those found with CAFA 3 for GO, moreover we found good performance for the other annotation sources. As with CAFA 3, Simpson index with Stouffer’s method led to the top performance in almost all scenarios. Conclusions DomFun shows competitive performance with other methods evaluated in CAFA 3 when predicting proteins function with GO, although results vary depending on the evaluation procedure. Through our own benchmark procedure, PPP, we have shown it can also make accurate predictions for KEGG and Reactome. It performs best when using FunFams, combining Simpson index derived domain-function associations using Stouffer’s method. The tool has been implemented so that it can be easily adapted to incorporate other protein features, such as domain data from other sources, amino acid k-mers and motifs. The DomFun Ruby gem is available from https://rubygems.org/gems/DomFun. Code maintained at https://github.com/ElenaRojano/DomFun. Validation procedure scripts can be found at https://github.com/ElenaRojano/DomFun_project.

Ten quick tips for sequence-based prediction of protein properties using machine learning

“…Predicting protein functional properties is still one of the most important tasks for bioinformaticians (e.g., [10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17]). Here, we collect 10 useful tips or guidelines representing best practices specifically for methods that generate predictions of protein functional structural properties using protein sequence data as input; Fig 1 illustrates several examples.…”

Functional characterization of prokaryotic dark matter: the road so far and what lies ahead

“…A multitude of in silico approaches have been designed to predict the function of the gene products inferred downstream from a given workflow, without the need to rely on inheritance through homology. Some examples include, but are not restricted to, predicting protein function by (i) inferring known patterns of evolutionary substitutions ( Bileschi et al., 2022 ); (ii) integrative mapping of metabolic pathways ( Calhoun et al., 2018 ); (iii) using domain-function associations ( Rojano et al., 2022 ); (iv) leveraging template-based protein structure prediction ( Zheng et al., 2022 ); (v) integration of multiple data sources ( Zohra Smaili et al., 2021 ); and (vi) genomic context analysis ( Cotroneo et al., 2021 ), among many others. Most current protein function prediction tools are based upon machine-learning (ML) ( Bernardes, Pedreira, 2013 , Bonetta, Valentino, 2020 , Libbrecht, Noble, 2015 ), to some extent.…”

Elucidating the functional roles of prokaryotic proteins using big data and artificial intelligence

“…This approach is so powerful because only a few model organisms have been probed in depth in laboratory studies, but many proteins are conserved across diverse taxonomic groups. Homology inference is applied in many annotation tools (Mahlich et al 2018 ), which can also be used to identify associations between protein domains and functions (Rojano et al 2022 ). However, even when a conserved domain is predicted, the function itself may not be conserved (Punta and Ofran 2008 ).…”