14Background: Genetic heterogeneity denotes the situation when different genetic architectures 15 underlying diverse populations result in the same phenotype. In this study, we explore the nature 16 of differences in the incidence of the number of hoof and leg disorders between Braunvieh and 17 Fleckvieh cattle in the context of genetic heterogeneity between the breeds.
18Results: Despite potentially higher power of testing due to twice as large sample size, none of 19 the SNPs was significantly associated with the number of hoof and leg disorders in Fleckvieh, 20 while 16 SNPs were significant in Braunvieh. The most promising candidate genes in 21 Braunvieh are: CBLB on BTA01, which causes arthritis in rats; CAV2 on BTA04, which in 22 effects mouse skeletal muscles; PTHLH on BTA05, which causes disease phenotypes related 23 to the skeleton in humans, mice and zebrafish; SORCS2 on BTA06, which causes decreased 24 susceptibility to injury in the mouse. Some of the significant SNPs (BTA01, BTA04, BTA05, 25 BTA13, BTA16) reveal allelic heterogeneityi.e. differences due to different allele frequencies 26 between Fleckvieh and Braunvieh. Some of the significant regions (BTA01, BTA05, BTA13, 27 BTA16) correlate to inter-breed differences in LD structure and may thus represent false-28 positive heterogeneity. However, positions on BTA06 (SORCS2), BTA14 and BTA24 mark 29 Braunvieh-specific regions.
30
Conclusions:We hypothesise that the observed genetic heterogeneity of hoof and leg disorders 31 is a by-product of multigenerational differential selection of the breedstowards dairy 32 production in the case of Braunvieh and towards beef production in the case of Fleckvieh. Based 33 on the current data set it is no possibly to unequivocally confirm/exclude the hypothesis of 34 genetic heterogeneity in the susceptibility to leg disorders between Fleckvieh and Braunvieh 35 because only explore it through associations and not the causal mutations. Rationales against 36 genetic heterogeneity comprise a limited power of detection of true associations as well as 37 differences in the length of LD blocks and in linkage phase between breeds. On the other hand, 38 multigenerational differential selection of the breeds and no systematic differences in LD 39 structure between the breeds favour the heterogeneity hypothesis at some of the significant sites. 40 41 Keywords: Braunvieh, feet and leg disorders, Fleckvieh, genetic heterogeneity, GWAS, 42 linkage disequilibrium, principal components 43 Background 44 Genetic heterogeneity denotes the situation when different genetic architectures underlying 45 diverse populations result in the same phenotype. In human genetics, for decades, the concept 46 of genetic heterogeneity has been considered in genome-wide association studies (GWAS) [1]. 47 One of the most well-known diseases characterised by high degree of genetic heterogeneity is 48 the human autism spectrum disorder [2]. Relatively recently the concept of genetic 49 heterogeneity has also been introduced into to the ana...