Dear Editor, The incidence of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) in tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is low (2.2-4.4%). 1,2 These tumours are morphologically heterogeneous but more frequently clear cell, papillary or chromophobe (CRCC) rather than other types. 3,4 In spite of this heterogeneity, a consistent von Hippel Lindau (VHL)-independent and alternate molecular pathway, associated with TSC1 and TSC2 gene mutations and consequent involvement of the mTOR signal pathway, has been proposed for RCC in TSC. 5 Recently, Schreiner et al. 6 described a 43-yearold patient with TSC and four concomitant RCCs in which neither cytogenetics nor molecular studies were performed. We report intra-operative cytology and subsequent histology of a case with similar morphology and immunohistochemistry in which a fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) study revealed several chromosome copy number changes.A 12-year-old boy had been diagnosed with TSC at 8 months. A routine follow-up renal ultrasound disclosed a partly exophytic nodule in the lower pole of the left kidney. A solid lesion with contrast enhancement and low lipid content was detected on magnetic resonance imaging. The tentative clinical diagnosis was atypical angiomyolipoma. A 30-g left partial nephrectomy was performed. The surgical specimen had a subcapsular, well-circumscribed solid tumour measuring 40 9 35 9 25 mm.The nodule was scraped on site and smears were prepared. Some smears were air-dried and stained with May-Gr€ unwald-Giemsa for immediate evaluation, whereas others were fixed in 95% ethanol for subsequent examination using haematoxylin and eosin. The smears were populated by nude nuclei and large epithelial-like cells, single or in acinar/papillary groups, on a finely necrotic background. The neoplastic cells had round, regular nuclei with frequent prominent eosinophilic nucleoli (Figure 1). Some bi-or multinucleated cells and rare atypical nuclei were seen. The cytoplasm was abundant displaying oncocytic features and occasional lipidic vacuoles. A preliminary diagnosis of probable RCC, not otherwise specified (NOS) was advanced. The hypotheses of oncocytoma and even of oncocytomalike angiomyolipoma were not definitely ruled out, as angiomyolipomas concurrent with oncocytoma, CRCC or RCC, NOS have been reported in TSC. 4,[6][7][8][9] Material was collected for FISH in order to look for translocations involving the TFE3/TFEB genes. 10 Histologically, the cells reproduced the cellular features previously described on our cytology: large cells with voluminous oncocytic cytoplasm, regular nuclei and prominent nucleoli, as well as some multinucleated and some pleomorphic cells. Focally, clear cell-type cells were seen. There were some necrotic foci. Mitotic activity was not evident. The tumour did not invade beyond the renal capsule but there were unequivocal signs of vascular invasion.Like the four tumours referred to by Schreiner et al., our case displayed a solid alveolar architecture composed of large oncocytic-like epithelial neoplastic cells that do not enti...