Association of High-Cost Health Care Utilization With Longitudinal Changes in Patient-Centered Medical Home Implementation

Abstract

IMPORTANCE In 2010, the US Veterans Health Administration (VHA) implemented one of the largest patient-centered medical home (PCMH) models in the United States, the Patient Aligned Care Team initiative. Early evaluations demonstrated promising associations with improved patient outcomes, but limited evidence exists on the longitudinal association of PCMH implementation with changes in health care utilization. OBJECTIVE To determine whether a change in PCMH implementation is associated with changes in emergency department (ED) visits, hospitalizations for ambulatory care-sensitive conditions (ACSCs), or all-cause hospitalizations. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This cohort study used national patient-level data from the VHA and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services between October 1, 2012, and September 30, 2015. A total of 1 650 976 patients from 897 included clinics were divided into 2 cohorts: patients younger than 65 years who received primary care at VHA sites affiliated with a VHA ED and patients 65 years or older who were enrolled in both VHA and Medicare services. EXPOSURES Clinics were categorized on improvement or decline in PCMH implementation based on their Patient Aligned Care Team implementation progress index (Pi 2) score. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Change in the number of ED visits, ACSC hospitalizations, and all-cause hospitalizations among patients at each clinic site. RESULTS The study included a total of 1 650 976 patients, of whom 581 167 (35.20%) were younger than 65 years (mean [SD] age, 49.03 [10.28] years; 495 247 [85.22%] men) and 1 069 809 (64.80%) were 65 years or older (mean [SD] age, 74.64 [7.41] years; 1 050 110 [98.16%] men). Among patients younger than 65 years, there were fewer ED visits among patients seen at clinics that had improved PCMH implementation (110.8 fewer visits per 1000 patients; P < .001) and clinics that had somewhat worse implementation (69.0 fewer visits per 1000 patients; P < .001) compared with clinics that had no change in Pi 2 score. There were no associations of change in Pi 2 scores with all-cause hospitalizations or ACSC hospitalizations among patients younger than 65 years. In patients 65 years or older, those seen at clinics that had somewhat worse PCMH implementation experienced fewer ED visits (20.1 fewer visits per 1000 patients; P = .002) and all-cause hospitalizations (12.4 fewer hospitalizations per 1000 patients; P = .007) compared with clinics with no change in Pi 2 score. There was no association between change in Pi 2 score with ACSC hospitalizations among patients 65 years or older. (continued) Key Points Question Is a change in patientcentered medical home implementation associated with changes in high-cost health care utilization in the US Veterans Health Administration health care system? Findings In this cohort study including 1 650 976 veterans, neither improvement nor decline in patientcentered medical home implementation was consistently associated with changes in the numbers of emergency department visits, ambulatory caresensitiv...

Using a theoretical framework to inform implementation of the patient-centred medical home (PCMH) model in primary care: protocol for a mixed-methods systematic review

“…Systematic reviews of the effectiveness of the PCMH [ 31 – 36 ] and individual studies [ 37 – 42 ] show mixed results. Sinaiko and Landrum [ 36 ] comment as follows: … Recent work identifies five domains to consider when interpreting findings of practice transformation: the practice setting, the organizational setting, the external environment, the implementation pathway, and the motivation for transformation.…”

Association between service scope of primary care facilities and prevalence of high-cost population: a retrospective study in rural Guizhou, China

“…Compared to the non-HC group, the HC population had a lower percentage of preventable ED visits and hospitalization costs, and regions with a greater density of primary care physicians reported greater levels of preventable spending for the HC population [ 12 ]. Another study also suggested that the non-HC population had over three times the rate of preventable utilization than HC patients [ 24 ]. No consistent association was found between changes in the capacity of patient-centred medical homes and the utilization of health care services among HC patients [ 24 ].…”

“…Another study also suggested that the non-HC population had over three times the rate of preventable utilization than HC patients [ 24 ]. No consistent association was found between changes in the capacity of patient-centred medical homes and the utilization of health care services among HC patients [ 24 ]. Additionally, clinics that provide complex care management did not reduce overall expenditures after discounting upfront costs [ 6 ].…”

The Patient-Centered Medical Home and the Challenge of Evaluating Complex Interventions

“…The Pi 2 score consists of 53 different elements, covering 8 domains, which are drawn from patient surveys, staff surveys, and measures of clinic operations. 1 This score has been used to assess many outcomes, covering all the dimensions of health care quality as well as staff satisfaction and burnout.…”