Associations Between Maternal Depressive Symptoms and Nonresponsive Feeding Styles and Practices in Mothers of Young Children: A Systematic Review

Abstract

BackgroundChildhood obesity is a significant global public health problem due to increasing rates worldwide. Growing evidence suggests that nonresponsive parental feeding styles and practices are important influences on children’s eating behaviors and weight status, especially during early childhood. Therefore, understanding parental factors that may influence nonresponsive parental feeding styles and practices is significant for the development of interventions to prevent childhood obesity.ObjectiveThe objectives of this systematic review were to (1) identify and review existing research examining the associations between maternal depressive symptoms and use of nonresponsive feeding styles and practices among mothers of young children (2-8 years of age), (2) highlight the limitations of reviewed studies, and (3) generate suggestions for future research.MethodsUsing the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic review and Meta-Analysis Protocols) guidelines, six electronic academic databases were searched for peer-reviewed, full-text papers published in English between January 2000 and June 2016. Only studies with mothers 18+ years old of normally developing children between 2 and 8 years of age were included. Of the 297 citations identified, 35 full-text papers were retrieved and 8 were reviewed.ResultsThe reviewed studies provided mixed evidence for associations between maternal depressive symptoms and nonresponsive feeding styles and practices. Two out of three studies reported positive associations with nonresponsive feeding styles, in that mothers with elevated depressive symptoms were more likely than mothers without those symptoms to exhibit uninvolved and permissive or indulgent feeding styles. Furthermore, results of reviewed studies provide good evidence for association between maternal depressive symptoms and instrumental feeding (3 of 3 reviewed studies) and nonresponsive family mealtime practices (3/3), but mixed evidence for pressuring children to eat (3/6) and emotional feeding (1/3). In addition, evidence for the association between maternal depressive symptoms and restricting child food intake was mixed: one study (1/6) found a positive association; two studies (2/6) found a negative association; whereas one study (1/6) found no association.ConclusionsThis review indicates that the results of studies examining the associations between maternal depressive symptoms and parental feeding styles and practices are mixed. Limitations of studies included in this review should be noted: (1) the use of a diverse set of self-report questionnaires to assess parental feeding practices is problematic due to potential misclassification and makes it difficult to compare these outcomes across studies, thus caution must be taken in drawing conclusions; and (2) the majority of included studies (6/8) were cross-sectional. There is a need for additional longitudinal studies to disentangle the influence of depression on parental feeding styles and practices. Nevertheless, given that depressive symptoms and feed...

Associations between infant and maternal characteristics measured at child age 5 months and maternal feeding styles and practices up to child age two years

“…The relationship between maternal psychopathology and maternal feeding styles and practices have previously been assessed in several studies [62,63,[68][69][70] and systematic reviews [71,72]. Our results are in concordance with this research, suggesting that maternal mental health issues may interfere with the ability to promote a healthier feeding environment with positive social interactions.…”

Relationship between maternal depression symptoms and child weight outcomes in Latino farmworker families

“…Several studies have noted that depressed mothers tend to feed their children in a less responsive fashion compared with mothers with normal mood (Goulding et al, 2014;Gross et al, 2013;Haycraft, Farrow, & Blissett, 2013;McCurdy, Gorman, Kisler, & Metallinos-Katsaras, 2014;Mitchell, Brennan, Hayes, & Miles, 2009). In a systematic review (Lindsay et al, 2017), two of three studies reported mothers with increased depressive symptoms were less likely to feed their children in a responsive manner. A nonresponsive feeding style may take several forms, being either forceful (strictly controlling the child's intake), indulgent (acquiescing to the child's wishes with little parental guidance), or uninvolved (allowing the child significant autonomy in making eating decisions; Hurley, Black, Papas, & Caufield, 2008).…”

“…Feeding style, the manner in which mothers interact with children in feeding situations, is one of the most plausible candidates for linking maternal depression, diet quality, and children's weight (Lindsay, Mesa, Greaney, Wallington, & Wright, ). As with parenting style, feeding style is often described in terms of the underlying dimensions of demandingness and responsiveness.…”

The relationship between COVID-related parenting stress, nonresponsive feeding behaviors, and parent mental health

“…Parent feeding behaviors have important implications for children's health outcomes, such as weight and the ability to self-regulate eating (Faith et al, 2004;Frankel et al, 2012). "Nonresponsive feeding behaviors" are characterized by parents failing to observe cues or listen to their children's feedback about hunger or fullness during feeding (Lindsay et al, 2017). Distrust in children's appetite, rewards around food, and pressure to eat all fall under the umbrella of nonresponsive feeding behaviors (Jansen et al, 2014).…”