Assumptions and confidence of others: the impact of socio-cognitive information on metacognitive self-regulation

Abstract

Self-regulated learning rarely happens in isolation and although there is a wide range of evidence that socio-cognitive information may impact decision making and learning, its role in metacognitive self-regulation remains understudied. Thus, we investigated how socio-cognitive information on assumptions and confidence in assumptions of an unknown other in a learning setting affects (1) changes in assumptions (i.e., convergence towards other), (2) perception of the other’s competence, and (3) the search for information (i.e., metacognitive and conflict-based regulation). In our empirical study, N = 60 students first read texts, then judged statements as being true or false and stated their confidence in these assumptions on an integrated confidence/answer scale, were then confronted with bogus information on the supposed answers of another learner (computer generated), and were then asked to (1) re-state their assumptions including confidence judgment, (2) judge the other’s competence, and (3) decide what statements they wanted additional information on. Results showed that learners (1) converged towards the other learner, (2) judged the other’s competence in accordance with the other’s stated confidence, and (3) regulated their learning based on their own (adjusted) confidence rather than on the presence or absence of socio-cognitive conflicts. This suggests that socio-cognitive information can affect how learners metacognitively evaluate own assumptions and thus impact self-regulatory processes, but also that confidence of others affects their perceived competence. Although the direct impact of socio-cognitive conflicts on regulatory processes remains unclear, this study fosters our understanding of self-regulated learning processes within social contexts.

Evaluating the online Resilience Skills Enhancement programme among undergraduate students: A double‐blind parallel randomized controlled trial

“…Synchronous physical group learning through tutorials may also promote experiential learning and communal synergies (Paul & Jefferson, 2019;Walsh et al, 2020), which are preferred learning methods for the current generation of university students (Seemiller & Grace, 2017). Furthermore, synchronous learning offers students with the opportunities to make new social networks, these interactions can promote social support which may in turn offer social influences on one's meta-cognitive self-regulation (Mellati et al, 2018;Schnaubert et al, 2021). However, traditional face-to-face approaches are resource-intensive due to their reliance on facilities and manpower when compared to computer-assisted instruction modes (Maloney et al, 2015;Singh, 2021).…”

Impact of anxiety and confidence in virtual reality‐mediated learning transferred to hands‐on tasks

“…When learners lack the confidence to answer questions at a cognitive level, they may refuse to answer questions or even conceal answers, impairing researchers' assessment of learner performance (Undorf et al, 2021). Schnaubert et al (2021) mention that it is crucial to focus on learning confidence because learners can determine how well they understand certain learning materials, how well their learning has developed, and how confident they are in their knowledge construction.…”

Which Front-of-Package Nutrition Label Is Better? The Influence of Front-of-Package Nutrition Label Type on Consumers’ Healthy Food Purchase Behavior

“…Thus, consumers may speculate that manufacturers providing richer information are more confident in their products. At the same time, people will judge the other party’s competence according to their confidence in presenting information [ 33 ], and people usually infer competence from the confident behavior of others [ 34 , 35 ]. Therefore, we believe that consumers will view manufacturers that provide richer information as more competent.…”