T he molecular property of chirality has intrigued both scientists and laymen for more than a century and a half. van't Hoff 1 was the first to postulate the existence of chiral molecules-nonsuperimposable forms that are mirror images of one another, as are left and right hands-as early as 1874, a quarter century after Pasteur 2 had shown that salts of tartaric acid exist as mirror image crystals.* Synthesized in the laboratory in the absence of a directing template, the leftand right-handed molecules of a compound, or enantiomers, will form in equal amounts (a ''racemic'' mixture). However, chiral molecules present in nature as part of living organisms are most often produced exclusively in one enantiomeric form. This property of single chirality is critical for molecular recognition and replication processes and would thus seem to be a prerequisite for the origin of life.3 Enantiopure molecules such as enzymes help to direct the synthesis of further enantiopure molecules in living organisms, with prominent examples being the D-sugars and L-amino acids that make up DNA and proteins, respectively. Similar strategies are used in laboratory asymmetric synthesis and catalysis, where we draw upon the natural pool of chiral molecules to provide building blocks for constructing new enantiopure molecules or catalysts. This leads logically to the question: what served as the original templates for biasing production of one enantiomer over the other in the chemically austere, and presumably racemic, environment of the prebiotic soup?This Perspective highlights two models for the evolutionary routes that may have been taken by simple molecules in a racemic prebiotic world to arrive at the high levels of enantiopurity inherent in modern biological molecules. . Soai's landmark discovery 6 of an autocatalytic reaction following these theoretical descriptions, and the subsequent mechanistic studies of the Soai reaction by the groups of Blackmond 7,8 and Brown, 7,9 provide proof of concept for such models. The second model 10,11,12 is an alternative mechanism based on the equilibrium phase behavior of ternary systems of amino acid enantiomers and solvent. Both models focus on identifying means for amplifying a small imbalance in enantiomeric concentrations (''asymmetric amplification''), while the possible origin of this initial imbalance is the subject of other discussions.3 These models offer dramatically different approaches for addressing the fundamental question of how molecular homochirality evolved in the complex molecules required for recognition, replication and ultimately for the chemical basis of life.
Autocatalytic Model for the Evolution of HomochiralityMore than sixty years ago, Frank 4 developed a mathematical model for ''spontaneous asymmetric synthesis'', or the autocatalytic production of enantiomerically enriched molecules from a near racemic mixture in the absence of an added chiral template. 13 He showed that a substance that acts as a catalyst in its own self-production, and at the same time acts to suppre...