Asymptotic Considerations Shedding Light on Incompressible Shell Models

Abstract

The incompressible singularity found in 3D elasticity when Poisson's ratio approaches 1/2 is not present in classical shell models, nor in the limit models obtained from 3D elasticity when performing an asymptotic analysis with respect to the thickness parameter. However, some specific shell models -such as the 3D-shell model -do retain the incompressible singularity. These observations raise the issue of how adequately shell models can represent incompressible conditions, which this paper aims at investigating. We first perform a combined asymptotic analysis of 3D elasticity with respect to both the thickness parameter and Poisson's ratio and we obtain a commuting property, which is very valuable as a justification of the concept of an "incompressible shell", and substantiates the use of classical shell models with incompressible materials. We then show that the 3D-shell model does not enjoy a similar commuting property; nevertheless we propose a simple modification of this model for which commuting is obtained, hence consistency with incompressibility is recovered. We also illustrate our discussions with some numerical results. (2000): 74K25, 74G10, 74S05. Mathematics Subject Classifications

A refined dynamic finite-strain shell theory for incompressible hyperelastic materials: equations and two-dimensional shell virtual work principle

“…The incompressibility constraint is used to eliminate the transverse normal strain, and based on which, a numerical shell theory with five parameters for a generalized orthotropic incompressible hyperelastic material was developed. In [6], Chapelle et al examined whether the plane stress assumption or the asymptotic limits of thickness can commute with the incompressibility constraint, justifying the usages of classical shell models and a modified 3D shell model in the incompressible conditions. In Kiendl et al [7], a shell theory for compressible and incompressible isotropic hyperelastic materials was developed based on the Kirchhoff-Love kinematics which includes the assumptions of zero transverse normal stress and straight and normal cross sections, and then an isogeometric discretization was introduced for numerical computation.…”

On a consistent finite-strain shell theory for incompressible hyperelastic materials

“…Itskov [31] proposed an orthotropic hyperelastic constitutive model, which is coupled with incompressible shell kinematics to deal with large strains and finite rotations of shell structures. Chapelle et al [32] analyzed whether the stress assumption or the asymptotic limits of thinness can be commuted with the incompressibility condition, which justified the usages of classical shell models and a modified 3D shell models under incompressibility condition. By using the normalΓ -convergence method, Li and Chermisi [33] rigorously derived the von Kármán shell theory for incompressible materials.…”

A 4-node 3D-shell element to model shell surface tractions and incompressible behavior

“…While sometimes effective, these elements display severe illconditioning when the shell becomes thin and when the shell is an (almost) incompressible medium [17,18]. To improve the element behavior and computational effectiveness, instead of displacement degrees of freedom, enhanced strains have been used, see for example Refs.…”