We report a study of mixtures of initially oppositely charged particles with similar size. Dispersions of silica spheres (negatively charged) and alumina-coated silica spheres (positively charged) at low ionic strength, mixed at various volume ratios, exhibited a surprising stability up to compositions of 50% negative colloids as well as spontaneous repeptization of particles from the early-stage formed aggregates. The other mixtures were found to contain large heteroaggregates, which were imaged using cryogenic electron microscopy. Electrophoretic mobility, electrical conductivity, static and dynamic light scattering and sedimentation were studied as a function of volume fraction of the mixed dispersions to investigate particle interactions and elucidate the repeptization phenomenon.