Attacks on Ukrainian healthcare facilities during the first year of the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine

Abstract

BackgroundAlthough the Geneva Conventions and Rome Statute demand protections for healthcare facilities during war, breaches of these protections are frequently reported. The ongoing war in Ukraine is no exception, with several healthcare attacks eliciting widespread condemnation. The Ukrainian Healthcare Center (UHC) has been collecting, verifying and documenting attacks on health infrastructure since the Russia-Ukraine War was launched. The aim of this study was to assess UHC documented healthcare facility attacks during the first year (24 February 2022 to 25 February 2023) of the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine.MethodsThe Berkeley Protocol on Digital Open Source Investigations was used to document healthcare attacks. Data collection included temporal factors, location, facility type, attack and weapon type, number of killed and injured healthcare personnel and civilians, and whether facilities were damaged, destroyed or attacked more than once.ResultsThere were 334 documented attacks on 267 Ukrainian healthcare facilities, with 230 facilities being damaged and 37 destroyed. General hospitals, primary care clinics, emergency departments and children’s hospitals were most frequently targeted. The majority of attacks took place during the first three months and in eastern Ukrainian oblasts. Heavy weaponry was employed in almost all attacks. The total number of casualties included 97 fatalities and 114 injuries.ConclusionsDuring the first year of the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine, there were 334 attacks on 267 Ukrainian healthcare facilities documented by the UHC. Heavy weaponry was commonly used, and the direct impact of attacks was considerable in terms of facility damage and casualty tolls.

Threat awareness and counter-terrorism preparedness of Dutch hospitals: A cross-sectional survey

“…4 Another concern is the reported increase of attacks on healthcare in armed conflicts, which is a daily occurrence in in many conflict zones, including Ukraine. 6 Furthermore, hospitals experienced more threats of violence since the COVID-19 pandemic and many hospitals had to intensify their security measures. 2 Nonetheless, emergency managers deemed the likelihood of a physical terrorist attack in their hospital relatively low.…”

“…5 Finally, there is a refractory pattern of attacks on healthcare in conflict zones, with 2022 marking the most violent year against health workers and facilities in the last decade. 6,7 Hospitals are vulnerable targets for acts of violent extremism and terrorism as they must remain easy accessible to the general public and because they are densely occupied with patients and staff 24/7. 4,8 Furthermore, the intrahospital presence of flammable materials, noxious gasses and radioactive chemicals could cause additional detrimental effects of an attack.…”

“Will you need this health at all? Will you be alive?”: using the bioecological model of mass trauma to understand HIV care experiences during the war in Ukraine

“…One year into the full‐scale invasion, 66 deliberate attacks on medical facilities have been documented, with 17 of them reporting civilian fatalities [4]. In addition, 1409 healthcare facilities were damaged and 186 have been destroyed [5, 6]. The war has severely impacted the provision of HIV services.…”