Attitudes and Beliefs of Parents Concerned About Vaccines: Impact of Timing of Immunization Information

Abstract

OBJECTIVES:To determine if giving vaccine-information materials before the 2-month vaccination visit to mothers with concerns about vaccine safety positively changed their attitudes and beliefs about vaccine safety. METHODS:Mothers who indicated concerns about infant vaccinations were recruited from 2 separate sites in Tennessee and California and were given vaccine information at 1 of 3 times: during a prenatal visit; a 1-week postpartum well-child visit; or a 2-month vaccination visit. A separate group of concerned mothers was assigned to be followed longitudinally at all 3 time points and was analyzed separately. The mothers reviewed a new vaccine-information pamphlet and Vaccine Information Statements (VIS) from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Attitudes and beliefs about immunization were assessed both before and after the review of materials with written surveys. RESULTS:A total of 272 mothers with immunization concerns participated in the study. After review of the materials, mothers in all groups were significantly more likely to respond positively to questions and statements supporting the safety and importance of vaccines. Mothers who received this information at earlier visits were not significantly more likely to respond positively than mothers who received the information at the child's 2-month vaccination visit; however, participating mothers did indicate a preference for receiving vaccine information before the first vaccination visit. CONCLUSIONS:Distribution of the vaccine-information pamphlet and Vaccine Information Statements significantly improved attitudes about vaccination regardless of at what visit they were provided. Allowing adequate time to review vaccine information, even if done at the vaccination visit, may benefit concerned mothers. Pediatrics 2011;127: S120-S126

Parents who refuse or delay HPV vaccine: Differences in vaccination behavior, beliefs, and clinical communication preferences

“…Consistent with prior research, 22,23 most respondents indicated that talking to a physician or reading an information sheet would be helpful for making a decision about HPV vaccination, although parents who reported refusal less often perceived these resources to be helpful. We were encouraged to note that, across respondent groups, relatively few parents believed that providers should never routinely recommend HPV vaccine.…”

Countering Vaccine Hesitancy

“…One study reported that the majority of mothers preferred receiving vaccine information before the initial immunization visit. 65 The provision of a VIS is required at each immunization encounter for each vaccine, and counseling about vaccine-preventable diseases and vaccine adverse effects is required to correctly bill for vaccine administration. If parents refuse vaccination, a vaccine refusal waiver, used by many pediatricians in the event of deviations from the recommended vaccine schedule, can be obtained from the AAP Web site (https:// www.…”

Vaccination uptake by vaccine-hesitant parents attending a specialist immunization clinic in Australia

“…43 Using this style, the physician can discuss both the vaccine and disease risks and benefits, supported by easily digestible written and online resources. 24,38,44,45 It is possible for a recommendation to vaccinate be included with such an approach.…”