Background: Though Granulosa cell tumors (GCTs) are the most common ovarian sex cord stromal tumors, they are very rare in extra ovarian sites with a handful of cases reported in retroperitoneum, broad ligament, fallopian tube, mesentery and even in the adrenals. Female Adnexal Tumor of probable Wolffian Origin (FATWO), which is also a very rare tumor comes up as its closest differential because of a significant overlap of topographic, morphologic, and immunohistochemical (IHC) features. Case Summary: Present case is of a post-menopausal female who complained of abdominal swelling and post-menopausal bleeding. On CT, she was shown to have a broad ligament mass (fibroid) which was excised. On histopathological reporting the tumor showed mainly the lesser known morphological variants of GCT that lead to difficulty in reaching at the exact diagnosis and a differential of an extraovarian GCT [eGCT] vs. FATWO was given which on IHC finally turned out to be an eGCT. Conclusion: Broad ligament is the site of two very rare tumors of the female genital tract, i.e. eGCT and FATWO which are close mimickers of each other not only on topography, but also on morphology and immunohistochemistry. Hence distinguishing between these two entities may be quite challenging for a pathologist, but aid of certain features can be taken to arrive at the diagnosis many a times.