Authoritarianism and the Functions of Courts: A Time Series Analysis of the Philippine Supreme Court, 1961–1987

Abstract

Focusing on the independent and powerful pre–martial law Philippine Supreme Court, we investigate the impact of the establishment and breakdown of authoritarianism on the court's performance of the functions of conflict resolution, social control, and administration. We develop hypotheses concerning and models of the impacts of the onset, consolidation, and breakdown of martial law authoritarianism under Ferdinand Marcos on that court's handling of the three functions. Using Box-Jenkins time series analysis methods, we assess the impacts of the onset, consolidation, and breakdown of Marcos's authoritarianism on the Supreme Court's functional performance. In our analysis, authoritarianism had no impact on the Court's performance of the conflict resolution function; authoritarianism's onset increased and its breakdown decreased the Court's performance of the routine administrative function; and authoritarianism's onset decreased but its consolidation increased the Court's performance of the social control function.

The Relationship Between Independence and Judicial Review in Post-Communist Courts

“…While questions about judicial legitimacy, review, independence, and political/social impact are now being explored in a comparative setting, many scholars examine these questions using single case studies (Haynie 1994; Melone 1996; Ramseyer and Rasmusen 2001; Sabaliunas 1996; Tate and Haynie 1993). This research provides detailed information about developments within a single country, but is limited in its ability to evaluate general explanations of judicial behavior.…”

Reflections on the Reach of Law (and Society) Post 9/11: An American Superhero?

“…But if you use the English terms, then haven't you simply entrenched an Anglo-American legal vocabulary and imposed foreign concepts onto an indigenous system? Similar debates exist in the literature today, for example, over how best to develop a comparative study of the institutional performance of courtsFwhether through aggregate quantitative analysis (Tate & Haynie 1993, 1994 or through ethnographic and historical work (Gillman 1994). The choice of one discourse over the other not only affects the development of the field but also reinforces the power of those who speak that language.…”

Die politischen Systeme Südostasiens

“…Die Vereinnahmung des Gerichts während der Diktatur hatte jedoch einen dramatischen Reputationsverlust zur Folge (Tate und Haynie 1993). Die Vereinnahmung des Gerichts während der Diktatur hatte jedoch einen dramatischen Reputationsverlust zur Folge (Tate und Haynie 1993).…”