Among orbital lymphoproliferative disorders, about 55% of diagnosed cancerous tumors are orbital lymphomas, and nearly 50% of benign cases are immunoglobulin G4-related ophthalmic disease (IgG4-ROD). However, due to nonspecific characteristics, the differentiation of the two diseases is challenging. In this study, conventional magnetic resonance imaging-based radiomics approaches were explored for clinical recognition of orbital lymphomas and IgG4-ROD. We investigated the value of radiomics features of axial T1- (T1WI-) and T2-weighted (T2WI), contrast-enhanced T1WI in axial (CE-T1WI) and coronal (CE-T1WI-cor) planes, and 78 patients (orbital lymphoma, 36; IgG4-ROD, 42) were retrospectively reviewed. The mass lesions were manually annotated and represented with 99 features. The performance of elastic net-based radiomics models using single or multiple modalities with or without feature selection was compared. The demographic features showed orbital lymphoma patients were significantly older than IgG4-ROD patients (
p
<
0.01
), and most of the patients were male (72% in the orbital lymphoma group vs. 23% in the IgG4-ROD group;
p
=
0.03
). The MR imaging findings revealed orbital lymphomas were mostly unilateral (81%,
p
=
0.02
) and wrapped eyeballs or optic nerves frequently (78%,
p
=
0.02
). In addition, orbital lymphomas showed isointense in T1WI (100%,
p
<
0.01
), and IgG4-ROD was isointense (60%,
p
<
0.01
) or hyperintense (40%,
p
<
0.01
) in T1WI with well-defined shape (64%,
p
<
0.01
). The experimental comparison indicated that using CE-T1WI radiomics features achieved superior results, and the features in combination with CE-T1WI-cor features and the feature preselection method could further improve the classification performance. In conclusion, this study comparatively analyzed orbital lymphoma and IgG4-ROD from demographic features, MR imaging findings, and radiomics features. It might deepen our understanding and benefit disease management.