“…In some cases, edtech research tends towards an 'engineering' vision of how to fix education with advanced technologies, as indicated by the emergence of discourses of 'learning engineering' or 'precision education' (Bartolomé, Rodriguez-Illera, & Lindín, 2018;Williamson, 2020). The production of learning science-based edtech effects evidence is also being elevated by new kinds of industry-led alliances and funders, and is not without its own politics (Ames, 2019;Perrotta, Gulson, Williamson, & Witzenberger, 2020).The second concern is that specifically 'critical' edtech research may need to evolve fast in order to both interrogate contemporary shifts in edtech with adequate nuance and depth, and to develop constructive responses/proposals to the wider field of edtech researchespecially given recent experiences with online education (Bayne et al, 2020). Our aim is certainly not to set up a false sense of conflict between different branches of edtech research.…”