Automation, job characteristics and job insecurity

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to analyze whether specific jobs characteristics, which experts have identified as being more automation proof, are associated with reduced job insecurity. Design/methodology/approach Data come from a recent survey providing information on sources of job insecurity as well as on detailed job characteristics. The analysis is based on various regression models. Findings People who have jobs that involve lots of personal interaction are less likely to be concerned about losing their job because of automation, or because of other reasons, and are more likely to think their job will exist 50 years from now. Having a creative job does not change these concerns. The share of respondents who fear losing their job to automation is fairly small, and those who do, typically fear other sources of job insecurity as much or even more. Practical implications Developing interpersonal skills is more likely to be an effective strategy for reducing job insecurity than developing creative skills. The findings further suggest that policies aimed at automation are unlikely to suffice for the elimination of worry over job loss, as many workers who fear automation at the same time feel there are other reasons that might lead to the loss of their job. Originality/value There are very few studies that link fear of losing one’s job to automation to a job’s characteristics. The survey used here is unique in the level of detail provided on job characteristics.

Automation fears: Drivers and solutions

“…That peer-pressure plays a role in influencing fears of automation is consistent with previous research (Madigan et al, 2017), showing that peerpressure is a factor influencing perceptions of technologies. The findings also show that a key characteristic of a person's job can influence a person's fear of automation, something consistent with the findings of Coupe (2019).…”

“…Therefore, people whose jobs comprise of predominantly automatable tasks have all the reasons to fear that they would be substituted by automation technologies. Coupe (2019), for example, finds that people whose jobs involve a lot of personal interaction are less afraid of losing their jobs to ATs. Therefore, the following hypothesis is formulated: H5.1.…”

The Impact of Job Insecurity on Organisational Citizenship Behaviour and Task Performance: Evidence from Robotised Furniture Sector Companies

“…Work has been a subject of transformation for a couple of centuries [ 1 , 2 , 3 ]. In particular, recently these changes have been accelerated by the rapid technological advancement [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ].…”

Artificial intelligence and human workers interaction at team level: a conceptual assessment of the challenges and potential HRM strategies

“…AI and human workers interaction: challenges and potential HRM strategies A significant amount of prior research has focussed on AI's challenges for HRM from the perspective of lost jobs (e.g. Coupe, 2019;Ivanov and Webster, 2019;Arslan et al, 2021), changed professional demands (e.g. Hmoud and Lszlo, 2019), need for new skills development (Malik et al, 2020;Arslan et al, 2021) and talent management dynamics (e.g.…”