A case of domestic violence is reported. The patient presented with the triad of injuries associated with the shaking of infants: retinal haemorrhages, subdural haematoma, and patterned bruising; this has been described as the shaken adult syndrome. This case report reflects the diYculties in diagnosing domestic violence in the accident and emergency setting. (J Accid Emerg Med 2000;17:138-139) Keywords: domestic violence; women; assault Domestic violence is an under-reported and major public health problem that often first presents to the accident and emergency (A&E) department. It accounts for half of all violent crimes against women, and two deaths per week have been linked to domestic violence in Britain.1 Indeed, the Department of Health has issued statements to ensure health professionals are aware of domestic violence in this context when patients present with consistent traumatic injuries.
2The following case report reflects the diYculties in diagnosing domestic violence in the A&E setting, and stresses the timely referral of such patients to the relevant authorities.
Case reportA 34 year old woman was brought to the A&E department by ambulance at 0400 hours with head injuries. When handed over from the ambulance crew an assault was queried, although the patient later stated she had fallen down stairs after moderate alcohol ingestion.Her initial blood pressure was 119/72 mm Hg, pulse 88 beats/min, her pupils were equal and reactive directly and consensually, and her Glasgow coma score was 13/15 (she was confused and was opening her eyes to command). Examination of the head showed bilateral periorbital ecchymoses, nasal bridge swelling and epistaxis, a right frontal abrasion, and an occipital scalp haematoma. Ecchymoses were also noted on her back and buttocks, being linear in fashion on both upper arms, and her underpants were torn. Initial skull and facial x ray films were normal, and she was admitted under the care of A&E for neurological observations.Over the next 24 hours, her Glasgow coma score improved to 15/15, but she had vomited five times and complained that her vision remained blurred. Visual acuity was only hand movements in the right eye and finger counting in the left. Ophthalmological review confirmed both retinal and preretinal haemorrhages in the right eye and a retinal haemorrhage on the left. Both maculae were aVected by the haemorrhage (fig 1). Haematological investigations, including a full blood count and a clotting screen, were within normal parameters, and computed tomography of the head revealed a small left temporal subdural haemorrhage with adjacent oedema.It was only after 48 hours and repeated advice that she should seek help and report the injuries to the police, that she admitted that domestic violence had occurred.Ongoing police and consultant medical review showed photographic evidence of patterned bruising to the upper arms, and also several circular burns to the face and arm, similar to the type caused by the deliberate Five weeks after the initial injury s...