The eukaryotic homologs of RecA protein are central enzymes of recombination and repair, and notwithstanding a high degree of conservation they differ sufficiently from RecA to offer insights into mechanisms and biological roles. The yield of DNA strand exchange reactions driven by both Escherichia coli RecA protein and its human homolog HsRad51 protein was inversely related to the GC content of oligonucleotide substrates, but at any given GC composition, HsRad51 promoted less exchange than RecA. When 40% of bases were GC pairs, the rate constant for strand exchange by HsRad51 was unmeasurable, whereas the rate constants for homologous pairing were unaltered relative to more AT-rich DNA. The ability of HsRad51 to form joints in the absence of net strand exchange was confirmed by experiments in which heterologous blocks at both ends of linear duplex oligonucleotides produced joints that instantly dissociated upon deproteinization. These findings suggest that HsRad51 acting alone on human DNA in vivo is a pairing protein that cannot form extensive heteroduplex DNA.Human Rad51 protein (HsRad51) is a member of the universally distributed class of RecA proteins that play important roles in homologous recombination and recombinational repair (1). In prokaryotes, the RecA proteins play roles in recombination, postreplication repair, and the repair of double-strand breaks (2). In eukaryotes, members of this class play roles in meiotic recombination, double-strand break repair (3, 4), and possibly immunoglobulin switch recombination (5). In the mouse, the requirement of Rad51 for embryonic survival (6, 7) reveals a vital role that has not been found in prokaryotes and lower eukaryotes.RecA protein from Escherichia coli promotes a search for homology by a single strand of DNA, and initiates an exchange between that strand and homologous duplex DNA. To carry out those complicated interactions, RecA protein forms a helical nucleoprotein filament on single-stranded DNA; and Rad51 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Homo sapiens form nucleoprotein filaments that resemble the one formed by RecA (8,9). Once the nucleoprotein filament has been formed, RecA requires no cofactors other than ATP to promote a rapid search for homology and an extensive strand exchange. Yeast, frog, and human Rad51, as well as human Dmc1, a homolog that is specifically expressed in meiosis, are DNA-dependent ATPases that carry out homologous pairing and strand exchange reactions that resemble those catalyzed by RecA protein (10 -14). However, the eukaryotic homologs differ from RecA in several notable respects. None of the eukaryotic enzymes appears to manifest the kinetic barrier to binding to duplex DNA (15), which in the case of RecA favors the loading of protein on single-stranded DNA; all hydrolyze ATP at a rate that is at least an order of magnitude lower than hydrolysis by RecA, and all promote recombination reactions much more slowly than RecA (10,11,12,14). Observations on human Rad51 showed that both phases of the recombination reaction, homol...