Background and Advantages of a Tiered EMS Response in a Large, Fire-Based EMS Model

Persse, Katarzyna Kimmel David

doi:10.4172/2375-4273.1000138

Cited by 2 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 20 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…A tiered system is said to improve efficiency and public safety by getting appropriate emergency resources faster to genuine and critical cases while reducing possible harm to ambulance crews and pedestrians from sirens-related accidents and multiple responding public safety units (Kimmel and Persse, 2015;Newberger and Braithwaite, 2022;Sanko et al, 2020).…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

The Scale Effects of EMS Dispatcher Prioritization on Cardiovascular and Respiratory Calls During Covid-19

Pitt¹

2023

Preprint

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Objective The purpose of this study is to evaluate the judgment of the Fire Department of NY Emergency Management System dispatcher’s statistical data on whether there was a categorical distinction in severity in critical and high risk cardiovascular and respiratory call prioritization during the Covid-19 lockdown period in the five boroughs of New York City. Methods Two models, an ordinal logit regression model with a proportional odds specification and a non-proportional odds ordinal model with log-scale effects are fitted and compared using Fire Department of New York EMS Incident Dispatch Data. Goodness-of-fit diagnostics—such as the test of scale effects and the convergence method—for ordinals models are also discussed. Results There were 730 more cardiovascular calls (or a 48.28% increase) in 2020 with a priority rank of P1, P2, or P3 when compared to 2019 call volumes. Similarly, there were 544 more respiratory calls in 2020 than 2019, a 74.22% increase. The vast majority of the increased cardiovascular and respiratory call types (1,241) in 2020 now included a fever-cough designation. For all call types, there was 24.28% increase in 2020. When a log-scale ordinal model is estimated and adjusted for scale effects, our data showed that respiratory calls had the highest odds ratio of 43.23% when compared to cardiovascular calls of 31.24% which meant that higher priority levels were more than often applied to these higher call volumes calls when compared to all other call types, everything else remaining constant. Among the boroughs, Queens showed the higher odds (25.26%) of being assigned a higher priority level than the other boroughs, given that Staten Island was omitted. The odds ratios for all categories of increased call volumes, including those fever-cough calls that appeared only in 2020, showed that higher priority levels were more often associated with lower call volumes. In the month of May, the odds ratio of 7.27% was the highest, while the month of June with an odds ratio of -8.77% saw that it was less likely calls were assigned when compare to the other months. In 2020, the odds ratio for that year was 11.72% when meant that higher priority call were assigned when compared to the previous 2019. Average response time showed lower odds at higher priority levels. Surprisingly, all disposition levels showed that higher priority cardiovascular and respiratory calls meant that patients were less likely to be transported. The number of calls cardiovascular and respiratory calls with priority 1, 2 or 3 in which patients were transferred totaled only 566 or 16.06% when patients pronounced dead at the scene are excluded. Conclusions Our analysis showed that FDNY’s EMS dispatchers made a severity distinction in their assignment of priority levels (P1, P2 and P3) to potential high risk cardiovascular and respiratory cases during the Covid-19 lockdown, even though very few patients were transported. A log-scale effects ordinal model is preferred over a proportional odds specification, particularly when potential heterogeneity is unobserved.

show abstract

mentioning

confidence: 99%

The Scale Effects of EMS Dispatcher Prioritization on Cardiovascular and Respiratory Calls During Covid-19

Pitt¹

2023

Preprint

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Mistriaged Advanced Life Support Patients in a Two-Tiered, Suburban Emergency Medical Services System

Bucher

Feldman

Joseph

2020

WestJEM

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Introduction: Emergency medical services (EMS) systems exist to provide prehospital care in diverse environments throughout the world. Advanced Life Support (ALS) services can provide advanced care including 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), endotracheal intubation and parenteral medication administration. Basic Life Support (BLS) can provide basic care such as splinting, wound care and cardiopulmonary resuscitation. ALS can release patients to BLS for transport to the hospital, and this is an area of high risk. Our study examines patients who were triaged and admitted to a critical care location, including an intensive care unit (ICU), cardiac catheterization laboratory, or operating room (OR). Methods: The analysis included data from 2007-2015 of all patients who were triaged. We evaluated demographics, admission diagnoses, and dispositions using descriptive statistics. Diagnoses were grouped into categories based on the system. Results: We found that 372/17,639 (2%) of patients were mistriaged to BLS and admitted to a critical care location. The average age was 64. The most common diagnosis categories were neurological (24%), gastrointestinal (GI)/abdominal pain (15%), respiratory (12%), and cardiac (12%). Conclusion: It is uncommon for patients triaged from ALS to BLS to be admitted to an ICU, catheterization lab or OR, with a rate of 2%. Neurological, GI, respiratory, and cardiac diagnoses were the most frequent categories of patient complaints that were mistriaged. This study should lead to further studies to examine this patient population.

show abstract

Background and Advantages of a Tiered EMS Response in a Large, Fire-Based EMS Model

Cited by 2 publications

References 20 publications

The Scale Effects of EMS Dispatcher Prioritization on Cardiovascular and Respiratory Calls During Covid-19

The Scale Effects of EMS Dispatcher Prioritization on Cardiovascular and Respiratory Calls During Covid-19

Mistriaged Advanced Life Support Patients in a Two-Tiered, Suburban Emergency Medical Services System

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About