Balancing expectations amidst limitations: the dynamics of food decision-making in rural Kerala

Abstract

BackgroundFood decision-making is a complex process and varies according to the setting, based on cultural and contextual factors. The study aimed to understand the process of food decision-making in households in rural Kerala, India, to inform the design of a dietary behaviour change intervention.MethodsThree focus group discussions (FGDs) and 17 individual interviews were conducted from September 2010 to January 2011 among 13 men and 40 women, between 23 and 75 years of age. An interview guide facilitated the process to understand: 1) food choices and decision-making in households, with particular reference to access; and 2) beliefs about foods, particularly fruits, vegetables, salt, sugar and oil. The interviews and FGDs were transcribed verbatim and analysed using qualitative content analysis.ResultsThe analysis revealed one main theme: ‘Balancing expectations amidst limitations’ with two sub-themes: ‘Counting and meeting the costs’; and ‘Finding the balance’. Food decisions were made at the household level, with money, time and effort costs weighed against the benefits, estimated in terms of household needs, satisfaction and expectations. The most crucial decisional point was affordability in terms of money costs, followed by food preferences of husband and children. Health and the risk of acquiring chronic diseases was not a major consideration in the decision-making process. Foods perceived as essential for children were purchased irrespective of cost, reportedly owing to the influence of food advertisements. The role of the woman as the homemaker has gendered implications, as the women disproportionately bore the burden of balancing the needs and expectations of all the household members within the available means.ConclusionsThe food decision-making process occurred at household level, and within the household, by the preferences of spouse and children, and cost considerations. The socio-economic status of households was identified as limiting their ability to manoeuvre this fine balance. The study has important policy implications in terms of the need to raise public awareness of the strong link between diet and chronic non-communicable diseases.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12889-015-1880-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Cultural adaptation of a peer-led lifestyle intervention program for diabetes prevention in India: the Kerala diabetes prevention program (K-DPP)

“…Within the Kerala context, this phase revealed the importance of a collectivist approach to behavior change techniques with decision-making at the family level. The need for such an approach has been further supported by more in-depth studies on health behaviors, particularly dietary behavior change in relation to NCDs in this population [64]. The paucity of evidence on community-based life style interventions in India made it imperative to define context-specific objectives and strategies for personal and environmental change.…”

Development of a Tool to Stage Households’ Readiness to Change Dietary Behaviours in Kerala, India

“…It therefore becomes a challenge regarding food choices and behaviour change, as decision-making is partly influenced by all individuals in the family by virtue of various power relations, and also by society [12]. In the context of rural Kerala in India, we have already found that dietary decisions are taken at the household level and that costs were the primary consideration, money costs in particular [13, 14]. The hierarchy of household members in terms of food preferences and the value ascribed to various foodstuffs were more important than their perceived health value [13].…”

“…In the context of rural Kerala in India, we have already found that dietary decisions are taken at the household level and that costs were the primary consideration, money costs in particular [13, 14]. The hierarchy of household members in terms of food preferences and the value ascribed to various foodstuffs were more important than their perceived health value [13]. Irrespective of their employment status, women’s identities, also strongly embedded as housewives and mothers had the primary responsibility to keep “husbands and children well fed” [15] (p. 266).…”

“…Irrespective of their employment status, women’s identities, also strongly embedded as housewives and mothers had the primary responsibility to keep “husbands and children well fed” [15] (p. 266). Hence, the responsibility for cooking may rest with the women, but the decisions are often dictated by the preferences of spouse and children [13, 14]. …”

Food taboos among pregnant and lactating mothers in Tumkur: a qualitative study

“…7 Irrespective of whether from urban or rural area people have their own beliefs and practices. 8 The roots of these kinds of customs and taboos are rational at times and some real origins cannot be traced. 9 Malnutrition is one of the most important risk factors for poor health, both directly and in directly.…”