Spinel oxide nanocrystals are attractive materials for photoinduced advanced oxidation processes that degrade organic pollutants in water due to their chemical stability and tunability, visible light absorption, and magnetic recoverability. However, a systematic understanding of the structural and chemical factors that control the reactivity of specific spinel oxide nanocrystal materials toward photoinduced degradation processes is lacking. This Perspective illustrates these knowledge gaps through an investigation into the impacts of surface chemistry and composition of spinel ferrite nanocrystals of formula MFe 2 O 4 (M = Mg, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn) on their ability to remove a model organic pollutant (methyl orange (MO)) from water. We identify two mechanisms by which the nanocrystals remove MO from water: (i) surface adsorption and (ii) photoinduced degradation under visible light irradiation in the presence of hydrogen peroxide via the photo-Fenton reaction. Nanocrystals that do not contain any surface ligands are more effective at removing MO from water than nanocrystals that contain surface ligands, despite our observation that the ligand-less nanocrystals do not form stable colloidal dispersions in water, while ligand-coated nanocrystals are colloidally stable. For many of the spinel ferrite compositions studied here, the fraction of methyl orange removal via adsorption to the nanocrystal surface in the absence of photoexcitation is larger than the fraction removed under irradiation. Our data indicate that the composition-dependent surface charge of the nanocrystals controls the degree of surface adsorption of the charged MO molecule. Overall, these results demonstrate that careful consideration of the impacts of surface chemistry on the behavior of spinel ferrite nanocrystals is required to accurately assess and subsequently understand their activity toward the photoinduced degradation of organic molecules.