Barriers to breast cancer screening in Singapore: A literature review

Abstract

Introduction: Breast cancer is a leading cause of cancer death among women, and its age-standardised incidence rate is one of the highest in Asia. We aimed to review studies on barriers to breast cancer screening to inform future policies in Singapore. Method: This was a literature review of both quantitative and qualitative studies published between 2012 and 2020 using PubMed, Google Scholar and Cochrane databases, which analysed the perceptions and behaviours of women towards breast cancer screening in Singapore. Results: Through a thematic analysis based on the Health Belief Model, significant themes associated with low breast cancer screening uptake in Singapore were identified. The themes are: (1) high perceived barriers versus benefits, including fear of the breast cancer screening procedure and its possible outcomes, (2) personal challenges that impede screening attendance and paying for screening and treatment, and (3) low perceived susceptibility to breast cancer. Conclusion: Perceived costs/barriers vs benefits of screening appear to be the most common barriers to breast cancer screening in Singapore. Based on the barriers identified, increasing convenience to get screened, reducing mammogram and treatment costs, and improving engagement with support groups are recommended to improve the screening uptake rate in Singapore. Keywords: Barriers, breast cancer, mammography, screening programme

“It Will Lead You to Make Better Decisions about Your Health”—A Focus Group and Survey Study on Women’s Attitudes towards Risk-Based Breast Cancer Screening and Personalised Risk Assessments

“…However, even with a nation-wide screening programme, over 60% of Singaporean females between the ages of 50 and 69 years do not attend regular mammography at recommended intervals [ 7 , 8 ]. Studies over the past 25 years showed little change in women’s barriers and motivations to attend mammography screening, with recurring main themes such as fear, cost, inconvenience, and a perceived lack of risk [ 9 , 10 ].…”

Feasibility of monitoring Global Breast Cancer Initiative Framework key performance indicators in 21 Asian National Cancer Centers Alliance member countries

“…In rural areas, poor health literacy, belief in alternative therapy, cancer fatalism, and lack of autonomous decision-making have been reported in many Asian countries. 34 Even in HICs like Singapore, where multiple channels for screening are available, screening uptake remains low indicating psychosocial barriers in these settings, 35 fear of the financial burden associated with the costs of breast cancer treatment has been reported, as the government adopts a co-payment mode for health services. 36 , 37 …”

Sociodemographic Factors Associated with Breast Cancer Screening Among Women in Serbia, National Health Survey

“…Through a thematic analysis based on the Health Belief Model, significant themes associated with low breast cancer screening uptake were identified. The themes are: high perceived barriers versus benefits, including fear of the breast cancer screening procedure and its possible out-comes, personal challenges that impede screening attendance and paying for screening and treatment, and low perceived susceptibility to breast cancer ( 16 ). Low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) grapple with restricted financial resources, apportioning relatively smaller segments to healthcare budgets ( 17 ).…”