Barriers to Mental Health Care and Predictors of Treatment Dropout in the South African Stress and Health Study

Abstract

Objective This study used data from the South African Stress and Health Study (SASH) to examine both structural and attitudinal barriers to treatment initiation among South Africans with mental disorders and to investigate predictors of treatment dropout. Methods Face-to-face interviews were conducted with 4,315 adult South Africans living in households or hostel quarters. The interview included a core diagnostic assessment of past-12-month mental disorders and assessments of disorder severity, service use, and barriers to treatment. Multivariate logistic regression models were used to determine predictors of not seeking treatment in relation to disorder severity and sociodemographic characteristics, as well as factors that were predictive of premature treatment discontinuation by participants who had received mental health treatment in the previous 12 months. Predictors of dropout were identified by cross-tabulation and discrete-time survival analysis. Results Of the 4,315 adults, 729 (16.9% weighted) met criteria for a mental disorder in the past 12 months. Across all levels of severity, the most frequently cited reason for not seeking professional treatment was a low perceived need for treatment. Among those who recognized the need but did not access treatment during the past 12 months (7.2%), attitudinal barriers to treatment seeking were reported more commonly than structural barriers (100% and 34%, respectively). Of the 182 respondents who received treatment (25% weighted), 20% discontinued prematurely. Various factors, such as substance use disorders and absence of health insurance, increased the odds of treatment dropout. Conclusions Low rates of treatment seeking and high treatment dropout rates for common mental disorders among South Africans are a major concern. Public health efforts to improve treatment of mental disorders should consider the multiple influences on treatment initiation and discontinuation.

‘I think my future will be better than my past’: Examining support group influence on the mental health of HIV-infected Rwandan women

“…Cross-sectional data from other studies corroborate the effect of social support on ART-adherence (Whetten 2008, Bruwer 2011, Chaumba 2011). Our findings suggest that continued education and repeated messages delivered by counsellors and peers complemented the less frequent communication with doctors about medication adherence, proper diet and health precautions.…”

“…Additionally, fear of gossip and a general lack of privacy have presented challenges in implementing and engaging women in psychological services (Hugo et al . 2003, Bruwer et al . 2011, Chaumba 2011).…”

A Process Evaluation of a Web-Based Mental Health Portal (WalkAlong) Using Google Analytics

“…Dropout from traditional treatment among those with mental illness is already a cause for concern [10]. The chronic nature of mental illness requires frequent assessments in conjunction with long-term management that is tailored to individuals’ needs [11].…”

Factors Associated With Treatment Initiation for Psychiatric and Substance Use Disorders Among Persons With HIV

“…Although a number of studies have examined predictors of initiation of substance abuse treatment and psychiatric outpatient service by including components of the Andersen model (28–31), few have been conducted with HIV-positive samples. In a study of HIV patients in the Boston area, who were primarily heterosexual and unemployed (32), self-reported initiation of outpatient substance abuse treatment was associated with need factors of having hepatitis C, being homeless, and having a drug dependence diagnosis and with the enabling factor of not having members of the social support network encourage drug use.…”