Bayesian hierarchical piecewise regression models: a tool to detect trajectory divergence between groups in long-term observational studies

Abstract

BackgroundBayesian hierarchical piecewise regression (BHPR) modeling has not been previously formulated to detect and characterise the mechanism of trajectory divergence between groups of participants that have longitudinal responses with distinct developmental phases. These models are useful when participants in a prospective cohort study are grouped according to a distal dichotomous health outcome. Indeed, a refined understanding of how deleterious risk factor profiles develop across the life-course may help inform early-life interventions. Previous techniques to determine between-group differences in risk factors at each age may result in biased estimate of the age at divergence.MethodsWe demonstrate the use of Bayesian hierarchical piecewise regression (BHPR) to generate a point estimate and credible interval for the age at which trajectories diverge between groups for continuous outcome measures that exhibit non-linear within-person response profiles over time. We illustrate our approach by modeling the divergence in childhood-to-adulthood body mass index (BMI) trajectories between two groups of adults with/without type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) in the Cardiovascular Risk in Young Finns Study (YFS).ResultsUsing the proposed BHPR approach, we estimated the BMI profiles of participants with T2DM diverged from healthy participants at age 16 years for males (95% credible interval (CI):13.5–18 years) and 21 years for females (95% CI: 19.5–23 years). These data suggest that a critical window for weight management intervention in preventing T2DM might exist before the age when BMI growth rate is naturally expected to decrease. Simulation showed that when using pairwise comparison of least-square means from categorical mixed models, smaller sample sizes tended to conclude a later age of divergence. In contrast, the point estimate of the divergence time is not biased by sample size when using the proposed BHPR method.ConclusionsBHPR is a powerful analytic tool to model long-term non-linear longitudinal outcomes, enabling the identification of the age at which risk factor trajectories diverge between groups of participants. The method is suitable for the analysis of unbalanced longitudinal data, with only a limited number of repeated measures per participants and where the time-related outcome is typically marked by transitional changes or by distinct phases of change over time.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12874-017-0358-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

BMI Trajectories Associated With Resolution of Elevated Youth BMI and Incident Adult Obesity

“…To better understand the BMI development in those who normalized their CVD risk by overcoming elevated BMI levels in youth and in those who increased their CVD risk by becoming obese adults, we used Bayesian hierarchical piecewise regression, an advanced multilevel growth curve modeling approach that allows us to estimate biologically meaningful and interpretable growth coefficients as well as between-person variability in key aspects of the BMI development across the life course. 36 Compared with the reference group, which included those who were not obese in youth or adulthood (Group I), the BMI of normal weight youth who developed obesity in adulthood was higher from age 6 years and increased significantly faster from youth until young adulthood (∼30 years), confirming that the roots…”

“…13 Therefore, we analyzed BMI data across the life course in the Cardiovascular Risk in Young Finns Study (YFS) 35 using Bayesian hierarchical piecewise regression. 36 Our primary aim was to model individual trajectories of BMI from youth to adulthood and investigate differences in trajectories across 4 a priori-defined groups based on BMI status (assessed once in youth and once in adulthood). 13,37…”

Prediction Models of Cognitive Trajectories in Patients with Nonamnestic Mild Cognitive Impairment

“…It also can enable identification, summarization, and communication of complex patterns in longitudinal data 17 . Group-based models have been applied to address questions related to developmental trajectories in psychology 18 , 19 , medicine 20 , and criminology 21 . Several studies have also used these models to facilitate causal inference in situations where randomization to treatment condition is not possible 22 , 23 .…”

Bayesian inference for a novel hierarchical accelerated degradation model considering the mechanism variation

“…For parameter inference, we adopt the Bayesian method which worked well in parameter estimation for models with multiple developmental phases. [20][21][22][23] Wang et al 22 applied the Bayesian method to infer the parameters of a change-point degradation model, and the numerical examples show that the Bayesian method gives decent parameter estimation results, which are more stable than those from maximum likelihood estimation method. Buscot et al 23 pointed out that the Bayesian method is a powerful tool to estimate the parameters in the piecewise model of the body mass index from childhood to adulthood.…”