Bayesian Network for Point and Diffuse Source Phosphorus Transfer from Dairy Pastures in South Otago, New Zealand

Abstract

Many factors affect the magnitude of nutrient losses from dairy farm systems. Bayesian Networks (BNs) are an alternative to conventional modeling that can evaluate complex multifactor problems using forward and backward reasoning. A BN of annual total phosphorus (TP) exports was developed for a hypothetical dairy farm in the south Otago region of New Zealand and was used to investigate and integrate the effects of different management options under contrasting rainfall and drainage regimes. Published literature was consulted to quantify the relationships that underpin the BN, with preference given to data and relationships derived from the Otago region. In its default state, the BN estimated loads of 0.34 ± 0.42 kg TP ha for overland flow and 0.30 ± 0.19 kg TP ha for subsurface flow, which are in line with reported TP losses in overland flow (0-1.1 kg TP ha) and in drainage (0.15-2.2 kg TP ha). Site attributes that cannot be managed, like annual rainfall and the average slope of the farm, were found to affect the loads of TP lost from dairy farms. The greatest loads (13.4 kg TP ha) were predicted to occur with above-average annual rainfall (970 mm), where irrigation of farm dairy effluent was managed poorly, and where Olsen P concentrations were above pasture requirements (60 mg kg). Most of this loading was attributed to contributions from overland flow. This study demonstrates the value of using a BN to understand the complex interactions between site variables affecting P loss and their relative importance.

Deconstructing Ecosystem Service Conflicts through the Prisms of Political Ecology and Game Theory in a North-Western Mediterranean River Basin

“…The conservationist sector was perceived as having a low-moderate level of influence. In line with the findings of Nash et al ( 2013 ) and Lucci et al ( 2014 ), the agricultural, tourism, and urban sectors can be “active and influential” agents, that is, agents capable of modifying the balance of ES flows.…”

Estimating dissolved phosphorus losses from legacy sources in pastures: The limits of soil tests and small‐scale rainfall simulators

“…There are modeling platforms (e.g., Bayesian Belief Networks) that use cause‐and‐effect relationships and probability theory that can be used to iteratively develop conceptually sound mechanistic (i.e., quasi process) models (Lucci et al., 2014; McDowell et al., 2009; Nash & Hannah, 2011; Nash et al., 2010, Nash, Waters, et al. 2013).…”

A decision analysis framework for development planning and performance measurement: application to land restoration investments

“…Developing capacity in decision analysis could be the single most effective development investment toward achieving land restoration and the SDGs. (Barton et al, 2016) Project the outcomes of coral restoration in the Philippines BN (Benjamin et al, 2017) Integration and participation in water resource planning in Italy BN Participatory river basin planning in Italy BN (Castelletti & Soncini-Sessa, 2007) Management support for a multipurpose reservoir in Italy BN Valuation of ecosystem services in the rangelands of Botswana MC Identify dryland ecosystem service trade-offs under different rangeland uses MCDA (Favretto et al, 2016) Multi-criteria approach to the Great Barrier Reef catchment diffuse-source pollution problem MCDA (Greiner et al, 2005) Habitat suitability modelling of rare species BN (Hamilton et al, 2015) Assist the management, monitoring and evaluation of development-orientated research BN (Henderson & Burn, 2004) Participatory management of groundwater contamination BN (Henriksen et al, 2007) Decision support for the US Environmental Protection Agency on protecting water quality AIE A review of Bayesian belief networks in ecosystem service modelling BN (Landuyt et al, 2013) Assess and visualize uncertainties in ecosystem service mapping BN (Landuyt et al, 2015) Assessment of several options to reduce sedimentation in small irrigation dams in Burkina Faso MC Evaluate complex multifactor problems using forward and backward reasoning for phosphorus loss in New Zealand BN (Lucci et al, 2014) Ex-ante assessment of uncertain benefits for multiple stakeholders in a water supply project in Kenya MC Explore social representations of adapting to climate change BN (Lynam, 2016) Management of riparian buffer strips BN (McVittie et al, 2015) Stakeholder-driven spatial modeling for strategic landscape planning in urban-rural gradients in the USA BN (Meyer et al, 2014) 28 *AIE= Applied Information Economics, AM=Adaptive Management, BN=Bayesian Network, MC=Monte Carlo, MCDA=Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, SDM= Structured Decision Making,…”