Beck’s creative challenge to class analysis: from the rejection of class to the discovery of risk-class

Abstract

Beck's rejection of the relevance of class in Risk Society has had an immense impact on both the fields of class analysis and the sociology of risk. In outlining a novel theory of the systemic importance of risks as side-effects and in making bold claims about how the production and distribution of risks are undermining class inequalities, Beck posed a highly influential challenge to both risk and class studies. Beck's impact on class analysis however has not been mainly due to widespread acceptance of his original claims about risk and class; rather, it has been research building upon Beck's work so as to critically depart from his conclusions through which Beck has made his contributions to the study of class. In seeking to identify the impact of Beck's work on the study of risk and class, this paper, firstly, outlines Beck's challenge to class analysis. It then proceeds to identify three key areas of research whose development was motivated by their critical engagement with Beck's work: the literature on risk and the continuity of class; the critical theory of the individualization of class inequality; and the political economy of risk-class. This paper then concludes by critically evaluating Beck's more recent, partial acknowledgement of risk inequalities by arguing that there are significant limitations in his account of class, but that his work continues to offer a valuable opportunity to inspire future work on class and inequality.

Risk and responsibility in the corporate food regime: research pathways beyond the COVID-19 crisis

“…53 As such, class privilege not only protects elites from risk, but also shapes and increases risk production itself, thus further exacerbating class inequalities. 54 Identifying risk-classes entails using sociological concepts and analytical categories to define social groups according to their positionalities and relative risks. Risk-class analysis could then provide a basis for directing redistribution in the form of reparations and mitigation payments in anticipation of future harms, such as those related to climate change.…”

Cold housing: evidence, risk and vulnerability

“…Important also to our understanding of the (uneven) distribution of risk is its coalescence among those with fewer economic, social, political and personal resources. For example, Curran (2013aCurran ( , 2013bCurran ( , 2018 has drawn together a number of critiques of Beck's work arguing that the original risk society thesis ignores the continuing impact of class within contemporary society. Broadly, Curran (2013aCurran ( , 2013b notes that risk remains unevenly distributed, and those most likely to be adversely affected remain the poor and otherwise disadvantaged.…”

Space, Place and Capitals in Rural Youth Mobility: Broadening the Focus of Rural Studies

“…The classes in the East European post‐socialist context have been recently described as yet ‘in the making’ and as different from Western classes in terms of their composition, their distribution (i.e., the sparse middle class), and the mismatch of cultural and economic capital (see Roberts and Pollock ). During the turn of the century, debates arose which questioned the usefulness of the concept of class altogether (Beck ; Pakulski and Waters ; for critique, see Paternoster ; Curran ). While for some, the concept has lost its heuristic force for comprehending social processes, others are calling for redefining its essence.…”