Behind the Targets? The Case for Coherence in a Multi-Scalar Approach to Carbon Action Plans in the Transport Sector

Abstract

The Paris Agreement requires radical action across all policy sectors and at all scales of government. This paper argues that without a clear framework for sectoral budget setting which takes account of interactions across spatial scales, incoherent and inadequate policy responses will result. Using a case study of the transport sector within the UK, which has committed to a zero carbon pathway in law, we look at three key elements which have to be considered in setting out a new framework: budget coherence, accounting coherence and policy coherence. Using top-down and bottom-up examples emerging from practices today in the UK, we demonstrate that there are no ‘optimal’ solutions but a set of choices, all of which appear to be better than the patchwork of approaches emerging in the absence of a framework. A multi-scalar approach is essential as transport crosses spatial boundaries and the policy system places different levers at different scales. Transparency will be beneficial for honesty with the public and the difficult politics this rapid transition necessitates. It will also mitigate against blame shifting across governments between and within scales and the resultant inaction which characterized the previous decade of supposed ‘climate action’.

The role of funding in the ‘performative decarbonisation’ of transport in England

“…The principal UK data set which compares local authority carbon emissions is territorial and so only counts movement in and across an area. Nottingham and Oxford are relatively compact cities with broader spatial economic geographies and so this assessment limits meaningful comparisons (Marsden & Anable, 2021). With those important caveats in mind, both appear in the lowest 20% of local authorities in terms of per capita transport emissions for the last reported period prior to the pandemic in 2019 (Department for Energy Security & Net Zero, 2023).…”

Planning to fail? How science can respond to reduced climate mitigation ambition

“…Of course, decarbonisation policy is developed and implemented in a multilevel governance setting and not wholly decided by the UK Government in Westminster. There are devolved national governments in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and local authorities also play critical roles, particularly regarding implementation and in major cities 14 . The Scottish Government has set a target for a 20% reduction in car kilometres by 2030 and the Welsh Government a reduction of 10% per capita.…”