Behind the times: a brief history of motivation discourse in problem-based learning

Abstract

That idea that problem-based learning (PBL) is more motivating that traditional education has been prevalent since the inception of PBL at McMaster University in the late 1960s. Evidencing this through empirical research, however, has proven to be a lot more problematic. This paper retraces how the discourse on motivation started from a laymen’s conception in the early days of PBL, and slowly evolved into a field of scientific inquiry in the 1980s and 1990s. However, looking at the evolution of motivation theory over the same period, we show that motivation discourse in the burgeoning literature on motivation and PBL remained largely wedded to the laymen’s approach, and failed to catch up with the new achievement-goal theory and self-determination theory approaches. This paper proceeds to analyse the explosion of studies on PBL and motivation after 2000, acknowledging efforts to move away from anecdotal accounts and provide theoretical grounding to the research. However, once again, we show that the majority of the research employed outdated motivational measures that do not fully grasp the complexity of contemporary motivation theory. The paper concludes on the observation that single-course and curriculum-wide research interventions have yielded no conclusive results on the effect of PBL on intrinsic motivation, and that future research should therefore seek to use up-to-date motivational constructs in more targeted interventions.

Motivation Discourse of Student's Personality in Educational Activity

“…Modern research proves that motivation is effectively influenced by: -innovative teaching methods (Khadzhiev & Rakhimov, 2019;Tiwery & Souisa, 2019); -problem-based learning (Wijnia & Servant-Miklos, 2019); -indirect learning through activities (Tsai et al, 2019); -learning through research (Chen, 2020), in particular the creation of startups (Jinhyuk & Hyuk, 2020); -extracurricular work (Shaffer, 2019) and non-formal education (Stancescu et al, 2018).…”

Features of Learning Motivation of Students-Choreographers in Conditions of Modern Military Conflicts

“…In the current conditions of aggravation of the domestic and foreign political situation of the world countries, and, accordingly, the complex processes of reforming the world education system, the problem of educating a comprehensively developed citizen is urgent; consequently, for this, expansion and effective, motivated use of educational resources is necessary (Tiwery & Souisa, 2019), (Wijnia & Servant-Miklos, 2019).…”

Distance Project-Based Learning During Lockdown and Learner’s Motivation

“…Among the numerous models of motivational processes, Self-Determination Theory (STD) (Deci & Ryan, 1985) appears to currently be the most researched and applied in the field of psychology (Ryan et al, 2019). Also, this theory is often used to explain students' motivations to learn (Hartmann & Gommer, 2019;Reeve, 2012) and to study motivation in PBL approaches (for example see Wijnia & Servant-Miklos, 2019). Based on SDT, people are motivated by three universal psychological basic needs: autonomy (feeling self-governed and self-endorsed), relatedness (feeling interacted) and competence (feeling competent) (Deci & Ryan, 2000a;Ryan & Deci, 2000b).…”