Beliefs about weight and breast cancer: an interview study with high risk women following a 12 month weight loss intervention

Abstract

BackgroundBreast cancer is the most common cancer in the UK. Lifestyle factors including excess weight contribute to risk of developing the disease. Whilst the exact links between weight and breast cancer are still emerging, it is imperative to explore how women understand these links and if these beliefs impact on successful behaviour change.MethodOverweight/obese premenopausal women (aged 35–45) with a family history of breast cancer (lifetime risk 17–40%) were invited to a semi-structured interview following their participation in a 12 month weight loss intervention aimed at reducing their risk of breast cancer. Interviews were carried out with 9 women who successfully achieved ≥5% weight loss and 11 who were unsuccessful. Data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using thematic analysis.ResultsThree themes were developed from the analysis. The first theme how women construct and understand links between weight and breast cancer risk is composed of two subthemes, the construction of weight and breast cancer risk and making sense of weight and breast cancer risk. This theme explores women’s understanding of what contributes to breast cancer risk and whether they believe that weight loss could reduce their breast cancer risk. The second theme motivation and adherence to weight loss interventions explains that breast cancer risk can be a motivating factor for adherence to a weight loss intervention. The final theme, acceptance of personal responsibility for health is composed of two subthemes responsibility for one’s own health and responsibility for family health through making sensible lifestyle choices.ConclusionBeliefs about weight and breast cancer risk were informed by social networks, media reports and personal experiences of significant others diagnosed with breast cancer. Our study has highlighted common doubts, anxieties and questions and the importance of providing a credible rationale for weight control and weight loss which addresses individual concerns. Counselling and health education material should be tailored to facilitate understanding of both genetic and modifiable risk factors and should do more help individuals to visualise the weight and breast cancer link.

Alcohol use and breast cancer risk: A qualitative study of women’s perspectives to inform the development of a preventative intervention in breast clinics

“…Recent work from our group showed that women were receptive to adding a brief “cancer prevention information session” to screening or symptomatic clinics (Sinclair et al, ). However, research also highlights factors that may make communication about modifiable risk factors challenging, including beliefs about the role of luck and genetics in developing cancer (Conway, Wyke, Sugden, Mutrie, & Anderson, ; Dumalaon‐Canaria, Hutchinson, Prichard, & Wilson, ; Wright et al, ).…”

Association Assessment among Risk Factors and Breast Cancer in a Low Income Country: Bangladesh

“…But midlife people stay at danger zone. The young people and BMI factors have little bit risk to developing breast cancer (Kruk, 2015;Wright, 2015). Pregnancy (Britt et al, 2007) and breast feeding (Mohaghegh et al, 2015) have also association to develop breast cancer.…”

‘For me it's about not feeling like I'm on a diet’: a thematic analysis of women's experiences of an intermittent energy restricted diet to reduce breast cancer risk

“…Our participants were women at increased risk of breast cancer, although our own and other evidence suggests that their motivation for weight loss and adherence to diets tends not to differ from dieters in the general population (10,31) .…”