Benefits of virtual reality based cognitive rehabilitation through simulated activities of daily living: a randomized controlled trial with stroke patients

Abstract

BackgroundStroke is one of the most common causes of acquired disability, leaving numerous adults with cognitive and motor impairments, and affecting patients’ capability to live independently. There is substancial evidence on post-stroke cognitive rehabilitation benefits, but its implementation is generally limited by the use of paper-and-pencil methods, insufficient personalization, and suboptimal intensity. Virtual reality tools have shown potential for improving cognitive rehabilitation by supporting carefully personalized, ecologically valid tasks through accessible technologies. Notwithstanding important progress in VR-based cognitive rehabilitation systems, specially with Activities of Daily Living (ADL’s) simulations, there is still a need of more clinical trials for its validation. In this work we present a one-month randomized controlled trial with 18 stroke in and outpatients from two rehabilitation units: 9 performing a VR-based intervention and 9 performing conventional rehabilitation.MethodsThe VR-based intervention involved a virtual simulation of a city – Reh@City - where memory, attention, visuo-spatial abilities and executive functions tasks are integrated in the performance of several daily routines. The intervention had levels of difficulty progression through a method of fading cues. There was a pre and post-intervention assessment in both groups with the Addenbrooke Cognitive Examination (primary outcome) and the Trail Making Test A and B, Picture Arrangement from WAIS III and Stroke Impact Scale 3.0 (secondary outcomes).ResultsA within groups analysis revealed significant improvements in global cognitive functioning, attention, memory, visuo-spatial abilities, executive functions, emotion and overall recovery in the VR group. The control group only improved in self-reported memory and social participation. A between groups analysis, showed significantly greater improvements in global cognitive functioning, attention and executive functions when comparing VR to conventional therapy.ConclusionsOur results suggest that cognitive rehabilitation through the Reh@City, an ecologically valid VR system for the training of ADL’s, has more impact than conventional methods.Trial registrationThis trial was not registered because it is a small sample study that evaluates the clinical validity of a prototype virtual reality system.

The Effectiveness of Computer-Based Cognitive Rehabilitation in Executive Functions in Patients with Multiple Sclerosis

“…The present study findings suggested no significant differences between the experimental and control group in terms of the pre-intervention mean values of the executive functions, although the posttest values were significant. These results therefore confirm the effectiveness of cognitive rehabilitation intervention in executive functions, which is consistent with literature (3,14,18,(21)(22)(23)(24)(25)(26)(27). A study entitled "the effectiveness of interventional program in executive function in MS" confirmed the effectiveness of this program in improving executive functions and verbal learning in MS patients in the experimental group compared to the controls.…”

Assessment of cognitive instrumental activities of daily living: a systematic review

“…This task revealed that the largest differences were found in the number of errors made by the clinical samples versus the healthy population. Other similar virtual tasks are the virtual city (Reh@City) [57], the virtual park and the virtual maze [58]. The last two scenarios were mainly used to assess orientation and spatial memory; the virtual maze was also used to assess trust and decision making [44].…”

Effect of virtual reality on cognitive impairment and clinical symptoms among patients with schizophrenia in the remission stage ： a randomized controlled trial

“…In regarding to cognitive function, many studies have demonstrated virtual reality could help mitigate cognitive function impairment in many disease conditions. Faria and colleagues found that post 12 sessions of VRT, stroke patients improved in global cognitive functioning, attention, memory, visuo-spatial abilities, executive functions (26). Another research showed post-stroke patients gain improvement in sustained attention after 24 sessions of VR training (27).…”