In the reaction between tryptophan indole-lyase (TIL) and a substrate
containing a bad leaving group (L-serine), general acid catalysis is required
for the group's elimination. During this stage, the proton originally bound to
the Cα atom of the substrate is transferred to the leaving
group, which is eliminated as a water molecule. As a result, the basic group
that had accepted the Cα proton at the previous stage has to be
involved in the catalytic stage following the elimination in its basic form. On
the other hand, when the substrate contains a good leaving group
(β-chloro-L-alanine), general acid catalysis is not needed at the
elimination stage and cannot be implemented, because there are no functional
groups in enzymes whose acidity is strong enough to protonate the elimination
of a base as weak as Cl- anion. Consequently, the group that had accepted the
Cα proton does not lose its additional proton during the
elimination stage and should take part in the subsequent stage in its acidic
(not basic) form. To shed light on the mechanistic consequences of the changes
in the ionic state of this group, we have considered the pH dependencies of the
main kinetic parameters for the reactions of TIL with L-serine and
β-chloro-L-alanine and the kinetic isotope effects brought about by
replacement of the ordinary water used as a solvent with 2H2O. We
have found that in the reaction between TIL and β-chloro-L-alanine, the
aminoacrylate hydrolysis stage is sensitive to the solvent isotope effect,
while in the reaction with L-serine it is not. We have concluded that in the
first reaction, the functional group containing an additional proton fulfills a
definite catalytic function, whereas in the reaction with L-serine, when the
additional proton is absent, the mechanism of hydrolysis of the aminoacrylate
intermediate should be fundamentally different. Possible mechanisms were
considered.